Key result
Cardiac MRI correctly diagnoses tumor type in 97% of pediatric cases compared to histology.
Why the study?
Individual centers have limited experience imaging rare pediatric cardiac tumors, and the diagnostic accuracy of cardiac MRI using predefined criteria had not been tested.
Does cardiac MRI accurately predict tumor type in children with cardiac tumors compared to histologic diagnosis?
Observational (n=78)
Blinded assessors
Yes
Does cardiac MRI accurately predict tumor type in children with cardiac tumors compared to histologic diagnosis?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Captured external expert commentary on this paper, strongest first. Original sources are linked where available.
“Beroukhim et al., an international group of cardiac imagers, present the cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings in a large number and variety of cardiac tumors in children.”
“Cardiac MRI offers superior imaging ability for cardiac tumors. It allows us to make more accurate measurements and to delineate margins and follow the tumor more carefully.”
Cardiac MRI can accurately predict the likely tumor type in the majority of children with a cardiac mass, though histologic diagnosis remains the gold standard.
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to report the results of an international multicenter experience of cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) evaluation of cardiac tumors in children, each with histology correlation or a diagnosis of tuberous sclerosis, and to determine which characteristics are predictive of tumor type. BACKGROUND: Individual centers have relatively little experience with diagnostic imaging of cardiac tumors in children, because of their low prevalence. The accuracy of cardiac MRI diagnosis on the basis of a pre-defined set of criteria has not been tested. METHODS: An international group of pediatric cardiac imaging centers was solicited for case contribution. Inclusion criteria comprised: 1) age at diagnosis ≤18 years; 2) cardiac MRI evaluation of cardiac tumor; and 3) histologic diagnosis or diagnosis of tuberous sclerosis. Data from the cardiac MRI images were analyzed for mass characteristics. On the basis of pre-defined cardiac MRI criteria derived from published data, 3 blinded investigators determined tumor type, and their consensus diagnoses were compared with histologic diagnoses. RESULTS: Cases (n = 78) submitted from 15 centers in 4 countries had the following diagnoses: fibroma (n = 30), rhabdomyoma (n = 14), malignant tumor (n = 12), hemangioma (n = 9), thrombus (n = 4), myxoma (n = 3), teratoma (n = 2), and paraganglioma, pericardial cyst, Purkinje cell tumor, and papillary fibroelastoma (n = 1, each). Reviewers who were blinded to the histologic diagnoses correctly diagnosed 97% of the cases but included a differential diagnosis in 42%. Better image quality grade and more complete examination were associated with higher diagnostic accuracy. CONCLUSIONS: Cardiac MRI can predict the likely tumor type in the majority of children with a cardiac mass. A comprehensive imaging protocol is essential for accurate diagnosis. However, histologic diagnosis remains the gold standard, and in some cases malignancy cannot be definitively excluded on the basis of cardiac MRI images alone.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Beroukhim et al. (2011) conducted an observational in Cardiac tumors (n=78). Cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) vs. Histologic diagnosis was evaluated on Correct diagnosis of tumor type by blinded reviewers. Cardiac MRI correctly diagnosed the tumor type in 97% of pediatric cases when compared to histologic diagnosis, though a differential diagnosis was included in 42% of cases.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: