Why the study?
Does bovine intestinal heparin differ from porcine intestinal heparin in structural composition and pharmacological effects?
Does bovine intestinal heparin differ from porcine intestinal heparin in structural composition and pharmacological effects?
Bovine and porcine heparins are not pharmacologically equivalent, as bovine heparin has a narrower therapeutic window that may lead to increased bleeding risk when used for antithrombotic protection.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Bovine heparin may carry higher bleeding risk per antithrombotic effect in animals; leaves open human equivalence and precludes practice change.
Increasing reports of bleeding and peri- or post-operative blood dyscrasias in Brazil were possibly associated with the use of heparin from bovine instead of porcine intestine. These two pharmaceutical grade heparins were analysed for potential differences. NMR analyses confirmed that porcine heparin is composed of mainly trisulfated disaccharides -->4-alpha-IdoA2S-1-->4-alpha-GlcNS6S-1-->. Heparin from bovine intestine is also composed of highly 2-sulfated alpha-iduronic acid residues, but the sulfation of the alpha-glucosamine units vary significantly: approximately 50% are 6- and N -disulfated, as in porcine heparin, while approximately 36% are 6-desulfated and approximately 14% N -acetylated. These heparins differ significantly in their effects on coagulation, thrombosis and bleeding. Bovine heparin acts mostly through factor Xa. Compared to porcine heparin on a weight basis, bovine heparin exhibited approximately half of the anticoagulant and antithrombotic effects, but similar effect on bleeding. These two heparins also differ in their protamine neutralisation curves. The doses of heparin from bovine intestine required for effective antithrombotic protection and the production of adverse bleeding effects are closer than those for porcine heparin. This observation may explain the increasing bleeding observed among Brazilian patients. Our results suggest that these two types of heparin are not equivalent drugs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vairo et al. (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: