Why the study?
The study aimed to compare a novel small event recorder device, the Carnation Ambulatory Monitor (CAM), with a standard Holter in dogs.
Does the Carnation Ambulatory Monitor provide comparable diagnostic value to a standard 3-lead Holter system over 24 hours in dogs?
Does the Carnation Ambulatory Monitor provide comparable diagnostic value to a standard 3-lead Holter system over 24 hours in dogs?
The Carnation Ambulatory Monitor is not suitable for quantitative arrhythmia analysis in dogs due to higher artefact rates and underestimation of complex arrhythmias compared to standard Holter.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
CAM should not replace standard Holter for canine arrhythmia analysis; leaves open refinements for veterinary ambulatory monitoring.
INTRODUCTION/OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to compare a novel small event recorder device, the Carnation Ambulatory Monitor (CAM), with a standard Holter. ANIMALS: Nineteen adult dogs. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Comparative and explorative study. The two devices were simultaneously applied for approximately 24 h. RESULTS: Analysis time (P=0.013) and percentage of artefacts (P<0.001) were greater for the CAM (110 min [40-264]; and 9% [0-34], respectively) compared to a standard Holter (30 min [18-270]; and 0.3% [0-9], respectively). The total number of beats (P=0.017) and maximum (P=0.02) and mean (P=0.037) heart rates were lower for the CAM (113,806 ± 23,619 beats; 227 ± 35 bpm; and 88 ± 22 bpm, respectively) compared to the standard Holter (131,640 ± 40,037 beats; 260 ± 64 bpm; and 92 ± 26 bpm, respectively). The minimal heart rate (P=0.725), number of pauses (P=0.078), duration of the longest pause (P=0.087), number of ventricular ectopic complexes (P=0.55), ventricular couplets (P=0.186), ventricular triplets (P=0.203), ventricular tachycardia (P=0.05), Lown grade (P=0.233), presence or absence of ventricular bigeminy, trigeminy, supraventricular tachycardia, and atrial fibrillation (P=0.98) did not differ. The CAM missed some relevant events, like complex ventricular arrhythmias, and the Lown grade did not match in 5/19 dogs when comparing the devices. CONCLUSIONS: Cardiac Ambulatory Monitor can be used to record ECG traces in dogs over a prolonged period, allowing to detect arrhythmias. Due to some clinically relevant limitations, including a higher percentage of artefacts, a longer reading time (which precludes quantitative counts of >300ventricular premature complexes), and underestimation of complex ventricular arrhythmias, the CAM appears not suitable for quantitative arrhythmia analysis in dogs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Schreiber et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: