This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Sir We read with interest the recent article by de Kok and colleagues, which reports on the introduction of a care programme to facilitate short-stay admission following breast cancer surgery. In line with previous national increases in short-stay breast cancer surgery we have previously conducted an audit of 162 breast procedures performed at the Princess Anne Hospital, Southampton, UK, from 1 to 24 October 2009. For this audit a day-case procedure was defined as a patient being admitted and discharged for operation on the same calendar day1. By this definition, 54 (89 per cent) of 61 breast-conserving procedures compared with four (10 per cent) of 39 mastectomies were performed as day-care procedures. In total, however, 84 per cent of patients who had a mastectomy went home on the day of surgery or the following day. Drains and axillary surgery did not influence successful day care. However, only a quarter of patients aged over 70 years, irrespective of operation, managed a day-care procedure. Adequate social support appeared to be the reason for a prolonged stay as an equal proportion of patients aged over or under 70 years had breast-conserving surgery. Our findings demonstrate that breast-conserving surgery, including axillary surgery, can be performed successfully as a day-case procedure. In women who require mastectomy the increased emotional impact and the requirement for solid social support necessitates a longer (overnight) stay for most women. This is supported by the recent call for protective legislation against ‘drive-thru mastectomy’ in the USA2. Finally, we note that in the study by de Kok the proportion of patients undergoing breast-conserving surgery was greater in the group treated after implementation of the care programme and wonder whether this might have confounded their results. For example, the documented increase in short-stay admission may have been mainly due to the increased proportion having breast-conserving surgery rather than a result of the care programme that they implemented.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robson et al. (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: