Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial highlights the ongoing controversy and differing expert opinions regarding the pathophysiological importance and clinical utility of salt restriction in hypertension management.
The issue of “salt and hypertension” has been a source of almost chronic controversy in medicine. Certainly, during this century some experts have regarded excessive salt intake as one of the major factors behind hypertension in westernised cultures [I]. Others have denied any etiological connections and expressed very critical views on the importance of salt for cardiovascular homeostasis [2]. On numerous occasions proponents and opponents have exchanged views either in the form of letters to the editor of various medical journals or during debates at major medical meetings. In this issue of BLOOD PRESSURE one of the gurus of antihypertensive treatment, Dr Edward D. Freis, presents his view on the role of salt in hypertension [3]. Dr Freis, who is well-known for his role in the initiation and conduct of the classic Veterans Administration Trials on Antihypertensive Treatment more than 20 years ago and who clarified the haemodynamic effects of many antihypertensive agents in early use, presents a view which is clearly in favour of salt being of pathophysiological importance in hypertension. According to Dr Freis, more or less vigorous salt restriction should be part and parcel of virtually any antihypertensive regimen. A different attitude towards the issue of salt in hypertension is presented by Dr John D. Swales [4], who is also internationally renowned for his research in hypertension and nephrology. Dr Swales expresses a very critical view indeed on the research that links salt and blood pressure, and if one were to follow his line of thinking few patients would ever be subjected to dietary advice aiming at salt restriction. While the two papers have not been written in an attempt to create yet another debate in this controversial area of medicine, it is nonetheless of great interest to read and consider the arguments presented in the two papers. It is remarkable that more or less the same data base can be interpreted in two so different ways. It is probably best left to the reader to decide for himself or herself which of the two opinions expressed here may be closest to the truth. Perhaps the view of another of the gurus in hypertension research, Bjorn Folkow, deserves to be reiterated: “On balance, therefore, the effects [of salt restriction] on blood pressure are minor except at such drastic reductions [to 10 mmol Najday] as to be in the long run unbearable” [2].
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hansson et al. (1992) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: