Why the study?
Does dietary sodium intervention alter blood pressure in untreated men and women?
Does dietary sodium intervention alter blood pressure in untreated men and women?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Salt sensitivity of blood pressure is a continuous variable common to the large majority of the population, strongly supporting the urgent need for a salt reduction strategy at the population level.
The concept of blood pressure salt-sensitivity refers to the interindividual difference in the blood pressure response to changes in dietary sodium chloride intake. According to Guyton's pioneer work, the phenomenon of salt-sensitivity implies the existence of interindividual differences in the slope of the pressure-natriuresis relationship [1], the individuals with the highest salt sensitivity having the steepest regression line. Ideally, blood pressure salt sensitivity should be estimated by well standardized protocols allowing the evaluation of the blood pressure response to different dietary sodium chloride intakes maintained for sufficiently long periods of time. Also, the different sodium chloride regimens tested should not diverge excessively from the levels of salt intake common to the majority of the population: in other words, extreme levels of salt restriction or salt load should best be avoided. Indeed, very few studies have been conducted along these lines. The great majority has adopted largely different sodium chloride regimens maintained for only a few days or have measured the blood pressure response to isotonic saline infusion, to diuretics, or both, according to various protocols. Despite these limitations, a large amount of information has been gathered on the phenomenon of blood pressure salt-sensitivity in the last two or three decades. A breakthrough in this area was the description of monogenic forms of hypertension caused by well characterized genetic mutations occurring at a single locus: these mutations were invariably associated with major alterations in renal tubular sodium handling [2]. These syndromes account for less than 1% of the prevalence of human hypertension, nevertheless their description led to the understanding that much more common subtle genetic alterations in anyone of the numerous factors involved in the control of renal sodium and water handling may concur to determine the individual susceptibility to hypertension. By this time, several allelic variants of candidate genes for hypertension have been reported to be associated with higher blood pressure levels and greater blood pressure salt sensitivity: in fact, the number of these ‘susceptibility’ genes is steadily growing up [3] also thanks to studies like GENSALT, aiming at localizing and identifying genes related to the blood pressure response to dietary sodium intervention [4]. This issue of the Journal of Hypertension publishes a report by Jiang He and the GENSALT investigators on some features of the blood pressure responses to dietary sodium intervention in the community-based GENSALT population, which was made of 1906 Chinese untreated men and women aged 16 years or older living in rural areas in northern China [5]. He's study is remarkable in several respects, the most important being the impressive sample size for a dietary intervention study, the feeding study design allowing strict monitoring of the participants' diet during the trial and the effort to achieve the best possible evaluation of the individuals' sodium intake by the measurement of electrolyte excretion in multiple urine collections. On the contrary, two major limitations in the protocol for the assessment of blood pressure salt sensitivity were the short intervention duration (1 week only) and the drastic change in sodium chloride intake (from 50 to over 300 mmol/day). Reportedly, the rationale of the investigators' strategy was the difficulty to perform a feeding study of longer duration in such a large population sample and the need to apply extreme regimens of dietary sodium intake to unmask, over a short period of time, the interindividual variation related to the genetic background [4]. Despite these limitations, He's report is of special interest to public health observers and to those engaged in cardiovascular prevention, first of all because it confirms in a carefully conducted study and in a very large population sample that blood pressure salt sensitivity is not a dichotomous but a continuous variable: in other words, there are no salt-resistant opposed to salt-sensitive individuals but only individuals with quantitatively different responses to changes in sodium intake. Indeed, this concept was already apparent in previous studies conducted in both hypertensive [6] and normotensive Caucasian individuals [7], however, the confirmation of those results is important in as much as it was obtained in a large population-based studies, in a different ethnic group and using a carefully applied dietary feeding model. The second important message coming from He's report is that the spectrum of individual responses in this study population ranged from a 32 mmHg fall to a 13 mmHg increase in systolic blood pressure when switching from habitual diet to low-salt intake and from a 26 mmHg increase to a 12 mmHg decrease upon switching from 50 to 300 mmol sodium per day. Similar findings were obtained for diastolic blood pressure. Systolic pressure was reduced by a least 4 mmHg in over 64% of study participants during the low-salt intervention and increased by at least 4 mmHg in approximately the same proportion of subjects during high-salt intervention. The proportion of participants who did not experience any fall whatsoever upon restricting sodium intake was only 23%, less than one-quarter of the study population. It should be noted, however that, as mentioned earlier, the degree of sodium restriction applied in this study was very large and much greater than that recommended by WHO [8]. In addition, the blood pressure responses were evaluated over a very short time (7 days only). A drastic change in sodium intake over such a short period of time conceivably induced a marked stimulation of the renin–angiotensin axis and the sympathetic nervous system [9,10]. These reactions are likely to have reduced the degree of sodium and volume-dependent changes in blood pressure and generated a number of nonresponders that would have probably not been apparent over a longer period of observation and with less drastic, more gradual changes in sodium intake. The authors emphasized in their report the finding of a gender-difference in the blood pressure response to both decreases and increases in salt intake. This difference, albeit highly statistically significant, after multivariable adjustment averaged 1.0/1.1 mmHg upon lowering sodium intake and 1.1/1.4 mmHg when reverting from low to high sodium intake, women being more sensitive than men. The authors highlight the need for further investigation but we believe they share the view that their finding is not such to justify any gender-based discrimination in preventive strategies at the population level. Much more impressive indeed was the impact of age and baseline blood pressure on the response to changes in dietary-salt intake. The participants with blood pressure levels above 140 and/or 90 mmHg experienced a fall of approximately 12/6 mmHg upon restricting salt intake, a result similar to what is expected from a powerful antihypertensive drug, whereas 9/4 mmHg was the average decrease observed in individuals aged 54 years or older: these results have a large impact in the modern aging society with very high prevalence of hypertension. One question that the GENSALT study will not be able to answer is about the impact of overweight and obesity on blood pressure salt sensitivity. The average BMI of the GENSALT study population was around 23 and the proportion of obese individuals extremely low: other studies, however, have highlighted the association between obesity and salt-sensitivity of blood pressure both in man and in animal models [11,12] and abnormalities in renal sodium handling have been demonstrated in relation to abdominal obesity [13], a factor that may exert a heavy impact in Caucasian and black populations in addition to those evidenced in He's work. In conclusion, the key message we may draw from this GENSALT study report is that salt sensitivity of blood pressure is common to the large majority of the population and exerts a particularly strong impact in middle aged and elderly people as well as in those with prehypertension or frank hypertension. This is all the more important in Caucasian, Hispanic and black ethnic groups in which the growing prevalence of overweight and obesity adds a further burden in this regard. These results strongly support the urgent need for a salt reduction strategy at the population level given the extremely large proportion of individuals at risk.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pasquale Strazzullo (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: