Why the study?
Because aortic hemodynamics affect vessel wall integrity and cardiac afterload, this study compared hemodynamics distal to biological and mechanical aortic valve replacements using in vitro 4D Flow MRI without in-vivo confounders.
Do biological aortic valve replacements compared to mechanical valves alter distal hemodynamics in an in vitro 4D Flow MRI model?
Do biological aortic valve replacements compared to mechanical valves alter distal hemodynamics in an in vitro 4D Flow MRI model?
In vitro 4D Flow MRI reveals that biological aortic valves induce accelerated and disturbed flow patterns distal to the valve compared to mechanical valves.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In vitro flow differences should not alter valve selection; leaves open clinical relevance pending in vivo validation.
BACKGROUND AND AIM OF THE STUDY: Aortic hemodynamics influence the integrity of the vessel wall and cardiac afterload. The aim of this study was to compare hemodynamics distal to biological (BV) and mechanical aortic valve (MV) replacements by in vitro 4D Flow MRI excluding confounding factors of in-vivo testing potentially influencing hemodynamics. METHODS: Two BV (Perimount MagnaEase [Carpentier-Edwards], Trifecta [Abbott]) and two MV (On-X [CryoLife], prototype trileaflet valve) were scanned in a flexible aortic phantom at 3T using a recommended 4D Flow MR sequence. A triphasic aortic flow profile with blood-mimicking fluid was established. Using GTFlow (Gyrotools), area and velocity of the ejection jet were measured. Presence and extent of sinus vortices and secondary flow patterns were graded on a 0 to 3 scale. RESULTS: A narrow, accelerated central ejection jet (Area = 27 ± 7% of vessel area, Velocity = 166 ± 13 cm/s; measured at sinotubular junction) was observed in BV as compared to MV (Area = 53 ± 13%, Velocity = 109 ± 21 cm/s). As opposed to MV, the jet distal to BV impacted the outer curvature of the ascending aorta and resulted in large secondary flow patterns (BV: n = 4, grades 3, 3, 2, 1; MV: n = 1, grade 1). Sinus vortices only formed distal to MV. Although physiologically configured, they were larger than normal (grade 3). CONCLUSIONS: In contrast to mechanical valves, biological valve replacements induced accelerated and increased flow patterns deviating from physiological ones. While it remains speculative whether this increases the risk of aneurysm formation through wall shear stress changes, findings are contrasted by almost no secondary flow patterns and typical, near-physiological sinus vortex formation distal to mechanical valves.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Oechtering et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: