Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Investing to prevent obesity and improve diets makes good economic sense. Poor diet and being above a healthy weight are leading risk factors for the burden of disease in Australia, together accounting for around 16% of the preventable burden.1 Currently, around 63% of Australian adults and 27% of children are overweight or obese, with the health system in danger of being overwhelmed in time.2 Between 1995 and 2011/2012, the proportion of people with a BMI of 35 or higher doubled.3 It is well understood that the consumption of unhealthy food is driving the obesity epidemic which is, in turn, influenced by the availability, price and promotion of ultra-processed foods.4 Unlike other chronic diseases, there are few effective, long-term treatments to manage obesity.5 A supportive environment could potentially halt the increase in individual weight gain over the life course, in both adults and children. The economic case for prevention is also compelling, with the annual cost of overweight and obesity estimated to be $8.6 billion, $3.8 billion in direct costs and $4.8 billion in indirect costs.6 Addressing the impact of unhealthy weight on workforce participation was a key reason for investment by the Federal government in the now defunded National Partnership Agreement on Preventive Health.7 For these reasons, I would argue that all the funding allocated, and more, be dedicated to a long-term comprehensive strategy to improve diets and support Australians to maintain a healthy weight. Given the proposed timeframe of four years to spend this additional funding, substantial resources are directed towards public education campaigns and support for community-based approaches which soften the ground for policy reform and support civil society to advocate for change. No country in the world has yet managed to turn around its rates of overweight and obesity,8 and despite a suite of strategies identified internationally as potentially being effective, implementation of these remains patchy in Australia.9 Many recommendations and proposals have been suggested by Australian governments to address overweight and obesity,10 but little progress has been made because these have not being implemented in a comprehensive or sustained way to be effective.11, 12 This could be rectified with the implementation and funding of a long-term strategy for healthy weight. A number of key policy components have been found to be effective and cost-effective in the Australian context, including restricting unhealthy food marketing to children, taxing unhealthy food and implementing interpretive front of pack nutrition labelling.13 A levy on sugary drinks to increase the price by 20% has been estimated to raise at least $400 million annually in Australia, even after the cost of implementation is taken into account.14 This could provide funds over and above what is proposed in this scenario for obesity prevention programs with a focus on low-income communities, an outcome which has strong support from the public.15 The conflicting messaging around sports sponsorship by unhealthy products and brands is undermining efforts to promote healthy diets, particularly to children. It is important to address this as part of a comprehensive approach to protect children from unhealthy food marketing. One solution to minimise the impact of restricting this practice would be to provide funds in the first instance to “buy out” these sponsorships, as was done in some Australian jurisdictions to reduce reliance on tobacco sponsorship. This would allow sports to transition to alternative sponsors over a three-year timeframe, after which the funding would wind down. The cost of implementation and monitoring of policy elements itself would be relatively cheap, but generating political priority for these issues is a highly challenging and lengthy process.16 The World Health Organization recommends the development of evidence-based public education campaigns around healthy diet and physical activity that are sustained and appropriately funded.17 The effectiveness of Australian mass media campaigns to address weight and diet has been found to be improved where campaigns are longer running, use multiple channels and target specific foods.18 Promising results from a public education campaign with a mass media component have been found in Australia with LiveLighter. The first phase of the campaign led to population-level increases in knowledge of health harms related to weight gain.19 The second phase focused on consumption of sugary beverages and associated risk of weight. The results from Victoria showed that the prevalence of adults drinking more than one litre of sugary drink per week reduced significantly (from 31% of adults down to 22%).20 The Cochrane review of community-based obesity prevention found that multifaceted and multilevel strategies are required to prevent obesity in children.21 A community-based approach recognises that obesity is a complex, multifactorial health issue that can be addressed by creating healthier environments for individuals to lead their daily lives. It covers settings that include workplaces, early childhood services, schools, higher education, recreational and sporting facilities. It supports the development of community-wide approaches to empower local solutions around healthy lifestyles. However, it can be challenging to create sustained ongoing interventions that work at multiple levels.22 These interventions can also require significant levels of funding to be sustained and effective.23 Competition for limited financial resources and short-term funding cycles is detrimental to collaborative efforts and limit community-based prevention programs from applying a multisetting approach to obesity prevention.24 Given these constraints, it is recommended that funding is dedicated to support the coordination and implementation of community-based system approaches, with a particular focus on vulnerable communities, which will be supported by the funding derived from a health levy on sugary drinks. At the end of the four-year period, if this investment in policies and programs is followed, we should see an improvement in diets and a slowing in the increase in the proportion of adults and children who are overweight or obese. We clearly need to do more to protect the health of the population and to minimise the devastating health and economic impact of overweight and obesity. Development of a national strategy with adequate investment to make it a reality is way overdue. We will never have perfect evidence, but we need to make a start and learn by doing, as we have so successfully with tobacco control. I have proposed a multifaceted approach that would include support for education, programs and policies—embedded in the development and implementation of a national healthy weight strategy. Australia is lagging behind in a number of areas, including with the imposition of a health levy on sugar-sweetened drinks; regulation to protect children under 16 years of age from exposure to unhealthy food marketing; a mass media national education campaign; and restrictions on sponsorship of sport by unhealthy food brands. It is also important that we are supporting communities who are motivated to make changes as well as those most impacted by diet and weight. Further, it is critical to monitor and measure change. Continuing to increase investment in the acute care system is merely putting the ambulance at the bottom of the cliff without building a fence at the top and as such is a triumph of hope over reality. The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest in connection with this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jane Martin (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: