Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Richard S. Peters's illuminating conception of education as initiation is among the leading ideas of contemporary philosophy of education.A new collection of essays, Reading R.S. Peters Today: Analysis, Ethics, and the Aims of Education, 1 has called attention to its contemporary relevance.After summarizing Peters's conception, I propose a major reconstruction, drawing on the distinction between general initiation, exemplified by obligatory tribal initiation rites at puberty, and particular initiations exemplified by voluntary rites of admission to fraternities or occupational guilds, for example.Peters's conception involves initiations to particular cultural practices.My reconstruction extends the idea to general initiation, firmly connecting education as initiation to rites of passage to adulthood. EDUCATION AS INITIATIONIn developing the idea of education as initiation Peters aimed to resolve longstanding conflicts between conservative notions of education as cultural transmission (the shaping or molding metaphor), and progressive notions of education as cultural regeneration (the growth metaphor).2 "Initiation" was offered as a middle ground.In Ethics and Education, Peters develops the idea in two stages.Chapter 1, offers a conceptual analysis with three conditions: to count as "education" something must (i) possess intrinsic value; (ii) conduce to knowledge, understanding, and the development of cognitive perspectives; (iii) not engage learners involuntarily or unwittingly.Chapter 2, then, puts forth education as initiation as a synthetic sketch fleshing out the analysis."Initiation" for Peters indicates learners and teachers joined in gaining knowledge, understanding, and active cognitive perspectives.To be an initiate in an activity is to know its traditions and rules, to understand its point, and to be able to participate as a social "insider"; initiates share, and care about, the values inherent in the activities.These two components -the conceptual analysis and the initiation metaphor -are closely linked: the initiation metaphor concretely reveals what is stated more abstractly in the analysis.I now turn to the main lines of criticism against his conception of education as initiation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Leonard J. Waks (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: