Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Editor—The systematic review by Edwards et al is helpful to those of us who routinely design and use questionnaires in our research.1 One area not covered by the review, which is important, is the quality of the response. Response rates are clearly important, but the quality of the responses is also important in that returned questionnaires with some questions either missing or incorrectly filled in will have the same effect as a poor response. In a pilot study of questionnaires for a trial among people with venous ulcers one of us (CPI) noticed that many items on the SF12 were either missed or incorrectly completed. The questions that were missed were those within the stem and leaf format of the SF12; questions in a self contained format were not missed. We therefore changed the layout of the questionnaire by altering all the stem and leaf questions to self contained ones. We then tested the revised version in a randomised trial among 1500 women aged 70 or over.2 The rates of questionnaires returned did not differ, but there was a large difference in the proportion of missing or incorrectly completed questions. Thus 26.6% of women missed or incorrectly completed at least one item in the standard version of the SF12 compared with only 8.5% for the revised version (difference = 18.1%, 95% confidence interval 11.1% to 25.1%). The quality of the revised version was tested in a factor analysis, which showed that it had similar internal reliability to the standard version. In short, therefore, attention should be given to factors that improve the quality of responses as well as to response rates.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2002 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: