Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction Genetic trials can provide comparative evidence on host performance under shared field exposure that is relevant to forest health surveillance, yet field evidence linking early foliar damage, spacing, and later plantation performance remains limited for Eucalyptus nitens under Atlantic conditions. Methods We analysed a partially imbalanced subset of trees from a Nelder spacing trial in northern Spain, focusing on two seed lots evaluated along a continuous spacing gradient. Tree-level foliar necrosis variables from a 2016 health assessment were related to survival and post-2016 growth measured through 2024. The study assessed field-expressed foliar necrosis under Atlantic sanitary conditions. Although the regional sanitary context is consistent with the occurrence of foliar diseases within the Mycosphaerella–Teratosphaeria complex, no tree-level pathogen confirmation was available. Analyses combined regression models with sensitivity analyses tailored to the clustered design and a leaf-level sensitivity analysis of necrosis severity. Results Lower planting density was consistently associated with lower foliar necrosis severity, higher survival probability, and greater post-2016 growth. EUNI-2 showed markedly higher observed survival to 2024 than EUNI-1 (92.5% vs. 70.8%; absolute difference 21.7 percentage points), and this survival advantage remained robust across sensitivity analyses. EUNI-2 also showed lower mean foliar necrosis severity than EUNI-1 (18.67% vs. 26.47%), but support for that contrast between seed lots was weaker under cluster-bootstrap inference. Leaf-level sensitivity analyses nevertheless indicated lower symptom intensity in EUNI-2 and towards the less dense end of the spacing gradient. Early foliar necrosis severity was not clearly associated with later growth. Discussion The most robust signals in this field subset were the consistent effect of spacing across sanitary, demographic, and growth responses and the survival advantage of EUNI-2. Taken together, the study shows that a structured genetic trial can generate useful comparative evidence on relative host performance for forest health surveillance and the evaluation and deployment of tree genetic resources under Atlantic plantation conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Benito-Delgado et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: