Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Chronic kidney disease (CKD) has become a global health issue with its prevalence of 9·1% which is roughly 700 million cases.[1] Diabetes and hypertension are the major causes for its occurrence contributing significantly to its poor outcomes. Cardiovascular diseases and infections contribute to its higher risk to mortality. The dismal monetary support, low per capita income along with poor sanitation, pollutants along with exposure to unknown nephrotoxins have been major contributors for CKD on the rise in Indian subcontinent.[2] The inherent inflammatory state resulting in deranged renal regulation of systemic homeostasis in CKD, defective immune status, and inappropriate nutrition compounded by comorbidities and poor socioeconomic background adds to the early occurrence of malnutrition.[3] The pooled estimate of the prevalence of malnutrition in India was found to be 56.7% with 95% CI ranging between 42.4% and 70.0%.[4-6] Malnutrition is a double-edged sword. It not only increases the risk to CKD occurrence and progression but also to cardiovascular events and death.[7-10] India being the seventh-largest and most populous country in the world the dietary habits reveal that the average protein intake in both rural and urban India is between <45 and 60 g/day by 73% and 70% in urban and rural areas.[11] Indian study demonstrated that malnutrition was seen in 7% in Stage III, 14% in Stage IV, 18% in Stage V, and 68% in Stage V-D in the upper-middle-class group while it was observed to be higher among all stages of CKD in low socioeconomic groups, i.e. 13% in Stage III, 26% in Stage IV, 40% in Stage V, and 93% in Stage V-D.[12] Malnutrition setting early in the course of CKD with dietary modifications as per KDOQI could worsen the inflammatory milieu and thus increasing morbidity and mortality. Poor oral intake, dietary restrictions, protein losses through urine and later stage by dialysis, intercurrent infection, metabolic acidosis, insulin resistance, malnutrition, hyperglucagonemia, and secondary hyperparathyroidism all add to worse outcomes in Indian context.[13] Growing evidence regarding maternal nutrition and altered nephrogenesis, with a permanent reduction in nephron endowment and detrimental consequences for offspring renal health.[14] It seems worthwhile to identify at-risk populations and develop future preventive strategies in Indian context as nearly 24% of women in South Asia having low body mass index[15] while 30% of women of reproductive age and 37% of pregnant women are anemic.[16] The concept of low dietary protein retards progression needs understanding, especially in Indian context, wherein already the patients are undernourished. Modification of Diet in Renal Disease study clearly demonstrated the inability of a low protein diet to prevent loss of GFR highlighting no advantage of protein restriction very early in CKD,[17] thus preventing malnutrition setting very early in CKD and this strategy could be reserved for advanced CKD where patients are near dialysis.[18] Need for better quality of protein rather than the quantity of protein can check the amount of acid production which is needed to be neutralized. Data clearly highlighting a strong dose-dependent relationship with red meat intake and increased risk of ESKD.[19] With an average Indian population already being undernourished and with the advent of newer armamentarium for better renal outcomes from evidence in DAPA CKD, CREDENCE, and FIDELIO trials.[20-22] Dietary restrictions should always be weighed upon the risk benefits over outcomes. However, few dietary restrictions are needed to prevent life-threatening hyperkalemia and metabolic acidotic states. We understand that the risk of kidney failure for a middle-aged person is 8% for men and 3% for women[23,24] thus patients would need to make and maintain this dietary change for decades to see a small benefit and, for the ≥90% of people who will never reach dialysis, no benefit at all. Having known the effects of protein-restricted diet in CKD population, more evidence is awaited in Indian population where vegetarian diets and diets with low protein are consumed mainly.[25] Thus, large prospective randomized controlled trials may be needed to examine clinical outcomes such as mortality benefit from nutritional interventions such as restricting dietary protein in CKD and end-stage renal disease.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A. Kaul (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: