Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Beta-adrenergic stimulation activates myocardial relaxation to a greater degree than alpha-adrenergic stimulation, suggesting distinct underlying subcellular mechanisms.
alpha-And beta-adrenergic inotropic effects have been shown to be qualitatively different. In order to further characterize these difference we compared the mechanical response to alpha- and beta-adrenoceptor stimulation, respectively, in electrically driven left ventricular papillary muscles from rat heart. The muscles were stimulated by either isoprenaline (Beta-adrenoceptor stimulation), phenylephrine in the presence of propranolol (alpha-adrenoceptor stimulation) or phenylephrine alone (combined alpha-and Beta-adrenoceptor stimulation). Isometric tension (T), rate of rise and decline of tension (first derivate=T') and rate of transition from tension rise to tension decline (negative part of second derivative=T') were recorded. These recordings disclosed qualitative differences between the alpha-and Beta-inotropic response both in dose-response and time course experiments. Maximal Beta-adrenoceptor stimulation caused a small increase in Tmax (18%), intermediate increases in T'max (45%) and T'min (68%) and considerable increase in T'min (145%) ("Beta-type" effect). Maximal alpha adrenoceptor stimulation increased all qualities by about the same degree (23-24% ("a-type" effect). While Beta-adrenoceptor stimulation gave a dose-dependent and pronounced increase in the ratio T"min/T'max (relaxation-onset index), alpha adrenoceptor stimulation decreased it to subcontrol values and phenylephrine alone gave a small dose-dependent increase at higher dose. The time course of the alpha-adrenoceptor stimulation was characterized by a transient decrease in all qualities followed by an increase which reached maximum at 4-5 min. Beta-Adrenoceptor stimulation gave a monophasic response which reached maximum after 1-2 min. Phenylephrine alone gave mainly an "a-type" effect although T"min increased significantly more in the absence than in the presence of propranolol and T"min/T'max showed a small increase which developed slowly. Thus Beta-adrenoceptor stimulation activated relaxation compared to contraction by a higher degree than did alpha-adrenoceptor stimulation. This probably reflects different mechanisms of action. While the alpha-effect may rely primarily on an increased calcium influx, the Beta-effect probably is the final result of several subcellular effects of cyclic AMP.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Skomedal et al. (1982) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: