Why the study?
Does esophageal Doppler monitoring accurately measure cardiac output compared to thermodilution during aortic cross-clamping?
Does esophageal Doppler monitoring accurately measure cardiac output compared to thermodilution during aortic cross-clamping?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While esophageal Doppler monitoring has significant quantitative limitations during aortic cross-clamping compared to thermodilution, it may still provide a useful qualitative guide to changes in cardiac performance.
Comment Clinical investigators have consistently reported significant reductions in stroke volume and cardiac index after aortic cross-clamp application. The extent of these hemodynamic changes may be influenced by the preoperative coronary circulation, myocardial function, the site of aortic cross-clamp application, the intravascular volume, the anesthetic techniques used, and the surgical pathology. Although thermodilution (TD) measurement of cardiac output remains the gold standard, other techniques evaluated have included transtracheal or suprasternal Doppler measurements of aortic blood flow and dioracic bioimpedance. Problems with suprasternal Doppler probe placement have limited its practical application. Earlier prototypes of esophageal Doppler monitors have been refined by the addition of good auditory and visual display of the ultrasound signal, thereby facilitating the determination of correct probe placement. The device used in this study was a 7-mm Doppler probe inserted into the esophagus after tracheal intubation. A 4-MHz continuous Doppler ultrasound was used, which presents both an acoustic signal and visual spectral analysis of the Doppler frequency shift on a real-time color display. The monitor performs on-line estimation of total cardiac output either by calibration with TD data or using a fixed stored normogram for manually imported biometric data, including age, sex, body weight, and height. As would be anticipated, stroke volume decreased during aortic cross-clamping, whereas systemic vascular resistance increased slightly. The esophageal Doppler measurements were, on average, approximately 20% lower than TD values during the preclamp period. During aortic cross-clamping, the bias for esophageal Doppler values increased to 1.51 L/min. Klotz and colleagues identified the inherent limitations of esophageal Doppler monitoring in this patient population. Measurement of absolute stroke volumes by this technology assumes a constant aortic cross-sectional area during systole and a constant distribution of cardiac output between the vessels originating in the aortic arch and the remainder, which constitutes flow in the descending aorta. This assumption may be invalid in patients with aneurysmal disease of the descending or abdominal aorta. Also, the relative distribution of blood flow between the supra-aortic vessels and the descending aorta may fundamentally change during aortic cross-clamping. Notwithstanding these limitations, esophageal Doppler monitoring may indeed have a useful role in patient management. Rather than a quantitative assessment of cardiac output, its role may be to provide a relative qualitative guide to changes in cardiac performance. Early identification of deterioration in left ventricular function may assist appropriate therapeutic interventions. This may be the most important contribution of Klotz and colleagues' study to future anesthetic practice.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Klotz et al. (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: