Subtle Cobalamin Deficiency

Editorials1 February 1996Subtle Cobalamin DeficiencyRalph Carmel, MDRalph Carmel, MDUniversity of Southern California School of Medicine Los Angeles, CA 90033Author, Article, and Disclosure Informationhttps://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-124-3-199602010-00010 SectionsAboutVisual AbstractPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissions ShareFacebookTwitterLinkedInRedditEmail As physicians, we tend to think of deficiency states in terms of their classic, generally florid features. In the case of cobalamin (vitamin B12) deficiency, these features include, first and foremost, megaloblastic anemia and neurologic dysfunction. Of course, all dividing cells are affected, but the sequelae outside the bone marrow and the nervous system are usually not clinically apparent.The theory that megaloblastic anemia is not invariably present in clinically overt cobalamin deficiency was first proposed 90 years ago [1] and was roundly rejected at the time. It has since been well documented that anemia and macrocytosis are often absent in cobalamin deficiency [2-4]. Indeed, humans may be alone in the animal kingdom in developing any megaloblastic anemia at all when they are cobalamin deficient. Interestingly, the bone marrow cells of cobalamin-deficient monkeys regularly show metabolic evidence of cobalamin insufficiency and impaired thymidine synthesis with the deoxyuridine suppression test, even though the cells never assume a megaloblastic appearance [5]. This metabolic insufficiency at the cellular level has since been shown in bone marrow cells of those cobalamin-deficient humans who do not develop megaloblastic anemia [6-9], many of whom also lack neurologic symptoms.These clinically silent deoxyuridine suppression abnormalities, which are reversible with cobalamin therapy [10], represent early deficiency in some of these patients; with time, the metabolic defect progresses and is translated into megaloblastic anemia. In other patients, however, such as the teenaged brothers with cblD mutation [6], clinical progression may be delayed or may not occur at all.Metabolic evidence of subtle deficiency has since been shown to extend beyond the bone marrow cells [9, 11, 12]. Homocysteine methylation to methionine is often impaired enough to increase serum homocysteine levels in patients who have no overt clinical findings. Methylmalonyl CoA isomerization is also frequently impaired, and methylmalonic acid levels in the blood increase. These tests are useful as long as proper techniques are used and causes of falsely elevated metabolite levels, such as renal insufficiency, are not present.Subtle, mild, or marginal cobalamin deficiency, thus defined as metabolic evidence of deficiency without the overt manifestations of anemia or neurologic disease, can now be shown by any of these metabolic tests [13], sometimes even without subnormal serum cobalamin levels [11]. Whether simply an early stage, a transient phenomenon, or a prolonged condition in its own right, subtle cobalamin deficiency is common. Certain groups or subpopulations, such as the elderly [11, 14], seem especially prone to it.However, the metabolic abnormalities, although noteworthy, may not necessarily be clinically important or require treatment. It is this problem that Fata and colleagues [15] address in this issue. They show that elderly patients with low cobalamin levels have significantly worse antibody responses to pneumococcal polysaccharides than do controls with normal cobalamin levels. This intriguing observation parallels previous descriptions of impaired antibody responses in patients with more severe cobalamin deficiency. It suggests that subtle immunologic impairment may also occur in patients with subtle cobalamin deficiency.As Fata and associates rightly point out, their findings are still preliminary. We do not know whether their patients with low cobalamin levels actually had metabolic evidence of deficiency; not all such patients do [9, 12]. We also do not know whether all of the controls with normal cobalamin levels were free of metabolic evidence of deficiency; again, this is not always the case [11]. Most importantly, we do not know whether mild deficiency caused the diminished antibody responses or simply coexisted with them. The antibody response in patients whose mild deficiency had been treated with cobalamin needs to be assessed.If borne out, the findings of Fata and colleagues would provide a clinical reason for treating all mild or subtle cobalamin deficiencies that are diagnosed, at least in the elderly. To date, electroencephalographic, evoked potential and mild neurologic deficits such as neuropathy or memory impairment have been the only clinically relevant sequelae identified in some patients with subtle deficiency [12, 16]. Cobalamin therapy usually reverses these mild and often subclinical neurologic and electrophysiologic defects [12].If we accept the plausible but unproven argument that biochemical abnormalities alone are not grounds for cobalamin therapy, under what circumstances should subtle cobalamin deficiency be treated? Three primary options are available: 1) Treatment can be withheld unless and until clinical abnormalities become obvious; 2) all patients found to have low cobalamin levels can be automatically treated; or 3) therapeutic decisions can be made after individual evaluation. Mild clinical defects, neurologic or otherwise, would be the clearest indication for treatment. Additional considerations could include any demonstration of underlying malabsorption of free [17] or food-bound cobalamin [18], because this would imply that the deficiency is not transient and will probably progress.The first option is supported primarily by studies showing no benefits from treatment and no ill effects from withholding it [19, 20]. However, clinical assessment in these older studies was based on blood counts and other insensitive criteria. Subtle clinical dysfunction and subtle improvement could have escaped detection. Sometimes, patients themselves are unaware of mild neuropathy or mild memory deficits until they are treated [21].The rationale for the second option is that cobalamin therapy is cheap and nontoxic, especially if given orally, and that it is simpler to treat everyone than to search for mild dysfunction. However, automatic treatment may encourage diagnostic attitudes that deemphasize the identification of underlying causes. Treatable underlying disorders or those that have important prognostic and other implications may be overlooked. Moreover, oral therapy may not be fully effective in the long run for patients who turn out to have underlying pernicious anemia, especially if the vitamin is taken haphazardly, as routine supplements often are. Oral therapy may also be excessive for persons who turn out to have no deficiency or only transient deficiency.The third option most closely meets the clinical ideal of specific diagnosis as the basis for the most appropriate treatment of each individual person. This option, however, has several disadvantages. The clinical evaluation may be relatively costly, especially when one considers that millions of people are probably affected. An equally serious problem is that despite its high prevalence, we do not yet know enough about subtle deficiency, the most effective ways to evaluate it, what its clinical impact really is, and the benefits of therapy.Indeed, the public health implications may extend beyond the usual clinical considerations. Other potential indications for therapy can be envisioned. One example is the issue of the possible cardiovascular benefits of decreasing the elevated homocysteine levels of cobalamin deficiency. Any subtle deficiency in young children raises developmental concerns. If fortification of the U.S. diet with folate is instituted to prevent some neural-tube defect births, cobalamin supplementation may need to be considered for all elderly persons and other persons who have increased risk for subtle cobalamin deficiency. We do not know whether the folate will render such persons susceptible to progression of the mild neurologic dysfunction that some of them have.The answers to the many questions about subtle cobalamin deficiency are unknown. Given the high prevalence of the phenomenon, these questions must be addressed soon by careful studies. Projections from existing data suggest that millions of elderly Americans have low cobalamin levels or metabolic evidence of cobalamin deficiency.References1. Langdon FW. Nervous and mental manifestations of pre-pernicious anemia. JAMA. 1905; 45:1635-8. Google Scholar2. Strachan RW, Henderson JG. Psychiatric syndromes due to avitaminosis B12 with normal blood and marrow. Q J Med. 1965; 34:303-17. Google Scholar3. Carmel R. Pernicious anemia. The expected findings of very low serum cobalamin levels, anemia, and macrocytosis are often lacking. Arch Intern Med. 1988; 148:1712-4. Google Scholar4. Lindenbaum J, Healton EB, Savage DG, Brust JC, Garrett TJ, Podell ER, et al. Neuropsychiatric disorders caused by cobalamin deficiency in the absence of anemia or macrocytosis. N Engl J Med. 1988; 318:1720-8. Google Scholar5. Goodman AM, Harris JW, Kiraly D. Studies in B12-deficient monkeys with combined system disease. I. B12-deficient patterns in bone marrow deoxyuridine suppression tests without morphologic or functional abnormalities. J Lab Clin Med. 1980; 96:722-33. Google Scholar6. Carmel R, Goodman SI. Abnormal deoxyuridine suppression test in congenital methylmalonic aciduria-homocystinuria without megaloblastic anemia: divergent biochemical and morphological bone marrow manifestations of disordered cobalamin metabolism in man. Blood. 1982; 59:306-11. Google Scholar7. Carmel R, Karnaze DS. The deoxyuridine suppression test identifies subtle cobalamin deficiency in patients without typical megaloblastic anemia. JAMA. 1985; 253:1284-7. Google Scholar8. Blundell EL, Matthews JH, Allen SM, Middleton AM, Morris JE, Wickramasinghe SN. Importance of low serum vitamin B12 and red cell folate concentrations in elderly hospital inpatients. J Clin Pathol. 1985; 38:1179-84. Google Scholar9. Carmel R, Sinow RM, Karnaze DS. Atypical cobalamin deficiency. Subtle biochemical evidence of deficiency is commonly demonstrable in patients without megaloblastic anemia and is often associated with protein-bound cobalamin malabsorption. J Lab Clin Med. 1987; 109:454-63. Google Scholar10. Carmel R. Reversal by cobalamin therapy of minimal defects in the deoxyuridine suppression test in patients without anemia: further evidence for a subtle metabolic cobalamin deficiency. J Lab Clin Med. 1992; 119:240-4. Google Scholar11. Pennypacker LC, Allen RH, Kelly JP, Matthews LM, Grigsby J, Kaye K, et al. High prevalence of cobalamin deficiency in elderly outpatients. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1992; 40:1197-204. Google Scholar12. Carmel R, Gott PS, Waters CH, Cairo K, Green R, Bondareff W, et al. The frequently low cobalamin levels in dementia usually signify treatable metabolic, neurologic and electrophysiologic abnormalities. Eur J Haematol. 1995; 54:245-53. Google Scholar13. Carmel R. Subtle and atypical cobalamin deficiency states. Am J Hematol. 1990; 34:108-14. Google Scholar14. Lindenbaum J, Rosenberg IH, Wilson PW, Stabler SP, Allen RH. Prevalence of cobalamin deficiency in the Framingham elderly population. Am J Clin Nutr. 1994; 60:2-11. Google Scholar15. Fata FT, Herzlich BC, Schiffman G, Ast AL. Impaired antibody responses to pneumococcal polysaccharide in elderly patients with low serum vitamin B12 levels. Ann Intern Med. 1996; 124:299-304. Google Scholar16. Karnaze DS, Carmel R. Neurologic and evoked potential abnormalities in subtle cobalamin deficiency states, including deficiency without anemia and with normal absorption of free cobalamin. Arch Neurol. 1990; 47:1008-12. Google Scholar17. Carmel R. Prevalence of undiagnosed pernicious anemia in the elderly. Arch Intern Med. [In press]. Google Scholar18. Carmel R. Malabsorption of food cobalamin. Bailliere's Clin Haematol. 1995; 8:639-55. Google Scholar19. Hughes D, Elwood PC, Shinton NK, Wrighton RJ. Clinical trial of the effect of vitamin B12 in elderly subjects with low serum B12 levels. Br Med J. 1970; 2:458-60. Google Scholar20. Waters WE, Withey JL, Kilpatrick GS, Wood PH. Serum vitamin B12 concentrations in the general population: a ten-year follow-up. Br J Haematol. 1971; 20:521-6. Google Scholar21. Green R. Typical and atypical manifestations of pernicious anemia. In: Bhatt HR, James VH, Besser GM, Bottazzo GF, Keen H, eds. Advances in Thomas Addison's Diseases. v 1. Clinical Developments in Adrenal Cortical Disease and Vitamin B12 Deficiency. Bristol: J Endocrinology & Thomas Addison Society; 1994:377-90. Google Scholar Comments0 CommentsSign In to Submit A Comment Author, Article, and Disclosure InformationAffiliations: University of Southern California School of Medicine Los Angeles, CA 90033Grant Support: Grant DK 32640 from the National Institutes of Health.Corresponding Author: Ralph Carmel, MD, University of Southern California School of Medicine, 2025 Zonal Avenue, Raulston 306, Los Angeles, CA 90033. PreviousarticleNextarticle Advertisement FiguresReferencesRelatedDetailsSee AlsoImpaired Antibody Responses to Pneumococcal Polysaccharide in Elderly Patients with Low Serum Vitamin B12 Levels Farid T. Fata , Barry C. Herzlich , Gerald Schiffman , and Arie L. Ast Metrics Cited ByBiomarkers and Algorithms for the Diagnosis of Vitamin B12 DeficiencyVitamin B12 and folate deficiency: should we use a different cutoff value for hematologic disorders?Homocisteína en la clínica humanaVitamin B12 deficiency in hypersecretors during long-term acid suppression with proton pump inhibitorsCorrespondenceMenopause and MidlifeVitamin B12Folate and vitamin B-12 status in relation to anemia, macrocytosis, and cognitive impairment in older Americans in the age of folic acid fortificationMethylmalonic acid and cognitive function in the Medical Research Council Cognitive Function and Ageing StudyHomocysteine and cognitive impairment; a case series in a General Practice settingFood-cobalamin malabsorption in elderly patients: Clinical manifestations and treatmentElevated Methylmalonic Acid Is Related to Cognitive Impairment in Older Adults Enrolled in an Elderly Nutrition ProgramDonnées actuelles sur la maladie de Biermer. À propos d'une étude rétrospective de 49 observationsAbsence of macrocytic anaemia in Alzheimer's diseaseHematologic Manifestations of HIV InfectionPrevalence of vitamin B12 deficiency in spinal cord injury11No commercial party having a direct financial interest in the results of the research supporting this article has or will confer a benefit on the author(s) or on any organization with which the author(s) is/are associated.The syndrome of food-cobalamin malabsorption revisited in a department of internal medicine. A monocentric cohort study of 80 patientsEfficacy of short-term oral cobalamin therapy for the treatment of cobalamin deficiencies related to food-cobalamin malabsorption: A study of 30 patientsCarences en vitamine B12 avec test de Schilling normal ou syndrome de non-dissociation de la vitamine B12 de ses protéines porteuses chez le sujet âgé. Étude de 60 patientsCobalamin Supplementation Improves Cognitive and Cerebral Function in Older, Cobalamin-Deficient PersonsDIARRHEA AND MALABSORPTION IN THE ELDERLYCobalamin and Folate Evaluation: Measurement of Methylmalonic Acid and Homocysteine vs Vitamin B12 and FolateAn Investigation of the Relationship Between Vitamin B12 Deficiency and HIV InfectionRandomized trial of the effect of supplementation on the cognitive function of older people with subnormal cobalamin levelsCerebrospinal fluid methylmalonic acid concentrations in neurological patients with low and normal serum cobalamin concentrationsEffect of Long-Term Gastric Acid Suppressive Therapy on Serum Vitamin B12 Levels in Patients with Zollinger-Ellison Syndrome 1 February 1996Volume 124, Issue 3Page: 338-340KeywordsAnemiaAntibody productionBone marrow cellsCellsCobalaminsElderlyFolic acidMegaloblastic anemiaMemoryNeuropathy Issue Published: 1 February 1996 CopyrightCopyright © 1996 by American College of Physicians. All Rights Reserved.PDF DownloadLoading ...