Key result
Poliovirus was detectable in sewage using Moore's method when excreted by approximately 1% of persons in the catchment area, with sewage virus amounts proportional to positive stool samples.
Why the study?
Does sewage sampling using Moore's method compare favorably to individual stool sampling for detecting poliovirus in a vaccinated crèche population?
Observational
No
Does sewage sampling using Moore's method compare favorably to individual stool sampling for detecting poliovirus in a vaccinated crèche population?
Sewage sampling using Moore's method can detect poliovirus if excreted by approximately 1% of the population, though identifying multiple simultaneous types requires systematic examination.
Sewage sampling may aid poliovirus surveillance at low prevalence; leaves open its role versus stool sampling in vaccinated crèches.
In a model experiment conducted in a Prague crèche, the detection rate for polioviruses in partially purified, non-concentrated sewage as sampled by means of gauze pads (Moore's method) was compared with that for individual stool samples. In the third week after the vaccination of children with live attenuated type 1 poliovirus (March 1975) and at an equal interval after their vaccination with a combination of types 2 and 3 (May 1975), corresponding poliovirus types were detected both in individual stool samples and sewage. The mean amount of sewage virus recovered during one week was directly proportional to the percentage of positive stool samples. After combined type 2 and 3 poliovirus administration, however, both types were only detected in one sewage sample, while in two samples type 3 only, and in one sample type 2 only, were identified. The results of the study indicate that poliovirus is detectable in sewage by the method employed if it is excreted by approximately one per cent of persons in the sewer catchment area of a small community. If a number of antigenic types are simultaneously present, their identification requires systematic examination of the sewage.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zdrazílek et al. (1977) conducted an observational in Poliovirus detection post-vaccination. Sewage sampling (Moore's method) vs. Individual stool samples was evaluated on Detection rate of polioviruses. Poliovirus was detectable in sewage using Moore's method when excreted by approximately 1% of persons in the catchment area, with sewage virus amounts proportional to positive stool samples.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: