Key result
Spinal anaesthesia for Caesarean section is associated with a small reduction in neonatal umbilical cord blood pH compared to general or epidural anaesthesia.
Why the study?
Does spinal anaesthesia reduce neonatal umbilical cord blood pH compared to general or epidural anaesthesia in women undergoing Caesarean section?
Does spinal anaesthesia reduce neonatal umbilical cord blood pH compared to general or epidural anaesthesia in women undergoing Caesarean section?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While spinal anaesthesia is safe and rapid for Caesarean sections, it may cause a small degree of fetal acidosis, prompting careful selection and management (e.g., prophylactic phenylephrine) in cases of fetal compromise.
Regional anaesthesia is the method of choice for Caesarean section and arguably, since the arrival of small gauge pencil-point needles, spinal anaesthesia has become the most popular technique in the majority of developed countries. In the UK, it accounts for the majority of elective and about half of emergency Caesarean deliveries [1]. Its advantages are well known: the rapid onset of a consistent, dense block is only offset by an increased incidence of maternal hypotension. In addition, trainees often find spinals technically easier and have more confidence in the quality of the block than that produced by topping up an epidural for Caesarean section [2]; this despite the reduced flexibility of a single shot technique. Regional anaesthesia for Caesarean section is undisputedly safer for the mother than general anaesthesia, but recently we have come to question whether it is necessarily safer for the baby. Studies have shown that subarachnoid anaesthesia tends to produce more acidosis in the neonate than does general anaesthesia [3]. In this issue, a thorough meta-analysis by Reynolds and Seed of relevant studies clearly demonstrates that there is a significant reduction in neonatal umbilical cord blood pH following Caesarean delivery under subarachnoid anaesthesia than either under general or epidural anaesthesia [4]. The pattern of pH change and the increase in base deficit in studies that measured it, point strongly to a metabolic as opposed to a respiratory cause for the acidosis, with fetal hypoxia the most likely culprit. Of course, meta-analysis has its weaknesses, with subsequent large trials not always confirming its findings [5]. The strength of the findings from meta-analysis ultimately depend upon the quality of the studies upon which it is based, and this is thoroughly discussed by Reynolds and Seed in their paper [4]. But the conclusion that spinal anaesthesia has a potentially harmful effect on the fetus is compelling. What is the true significance of these findings? The magnitude of the average reduction in pH is small, in the order of just 0.015. So is this a case of statistical but not necessarily clinical significance? Most of the relevant studies, however, are during elective Caesarean section, with only two relatively small, randomised studies including emergency Caesarean delivery [6,7]. This is an important point as we have insufficient information about the relative effects of the type of anaesthesia on acid-base balance where fetal compromise already exists such as in Caesarean section for fetal distress. Other situations where the fetus is more vulnerable include maternal pre-eclampsia or fetal prematurity. Could the effect on neonatal well-being be greater in these situations where the fetus is already stressed and has reduced reserves? More research is required in these areas to answer this question. Fetal metabolic acidosis can arise for many reasons. Contributing factors include aortocaval compression and other causes of reduced placental perfusion, prolonged uterine incision to delivery time, and maternal hypoxaemia, to name but a few. Any effect from spinal anaesthesia, regardless of its magnitude, has to be seen in the context of these other potentially contributing factors. Maternal oxygen administration before delivery increases fetal oxygen tension and reserves [8,9] in preparation for any interruption in placental perfusion during delivery. Although this practice has been questioned during elective Caesarean section [10] because of fears that fetal hyperoxia encourages the formation of harmful free radicals [11], it nonetheless seems sensible to administer oxygen to the mother when there is potential or actual fetal compromise. Why does spinal anaesthesia produce this tendency towards fetal acidosis? Subarachnoid anaesthesia is associated with greater haemodynamic disturbance than other regional techniques. We easily recognise maternal hypotension but probably cardiac output is more important to placental perfusion and fetal well-being. Thus, there can be reduced placental perfusion without maternal hypotension, as maternal physiology preferentially preserves cerebral and cardiac circulation ahead of placental perfusion. Hypotension induced by spinal anaesthesia cannot be viewed out of context of the effect of maternal position and aortocaval compression. Probably, some degree of left pelvic tilt is universally practiced during Caesarean section but whether it is effectively performed is another matter. The full left lateral position produces the least effect on cardiac output and placental perfusion [12] but moving a partially paralysed woman is difficult [13] and a return to the supine wedged position is necessary before surgery can start. Reynolds and Seed conclude that larger doses of ephedrine in patients following spinal anaesthesia contributed to the decreased umbilical cord pH [4]. But as maternal hypotension necessitating treatment with vasopressors is more common following spinal anaesthesia and as ephedrine is the most common vasopressor used, it could be an incidental factor. That said, there is increasing evidence from elsewhere that ephedrine may not be the most suitable vasopressor for obstetric use. The traditional view, based on sheep placenta work more than 30 years ago, is that ephedrine causes less placental vasoconstriction than alpha-adrenergic stimulants [14–15]. That view has recently been challenged. There is increasing evidence that phenylephrine and metaraminol used as vasopressors produce less depression of cord pH than ephedrine [16]. There are a number of possible explanations for this [16]. Ephedrine displays tachyphylaxis and frequently large doses are required to treat hypotension. It has a slow onset of action and is thus not ideal at treating sudden hypotension. Finally, as ephedrine crosses the placenta, it is possible that acidosis is the result of a direct fetal effect. Regardless of which vasopressor we choose, it remains to be seen how best to administer it. Is infusion better than bolus administration and should we give it prophylactically or wait until hypotension develops? Attempts have been made to answer these questions [17–19] but the results are inconclusive. The fact that placental hypoperfusion may occur before maternal hypotension is manifest suggests that there may be some merit in prophylactic administration. In the light of Reynolds and Seed's analysis, do we need to re-evaluate our use of spinal anaesthesia for Caesarean section? It is unlikely that the small degree of fetal acidosis caused by spinal anaesthesia has much effect on the healthy, elective, term fetus. But what should we do when the baby is compromised? When there is no need for immediate delivery, it would seem sensible to avoid further stress to the fetus and choose epidural anaesthesia. This is relatively uncontroversial; the difficulty comes when there is a need for immediate delivery and the rapid onset of spinal anaesthesia makes it the natural choice for regional anaesthesia. It comes down to a risk-benefit analysis to both mother and baby in the individual situation. As epidural compared to spinal anaesthesia will delay surgery by about 15–20 min, it is necessary to evaluate any harm this delay will cause the baby. General anaesthesia, although potentially beneficial to the baby, allows rapid delivery similar to spinal anaesthesia but will expose the mother to greater risk and is likely to be unpopular with her. Spinal anaesthesia will allow safe and rapid delivery but we now appreciate may further stress the baby. Low dose combined spinal-epidural anaesthesia, which produces readiness for surgery closer to that of spinal than epidural anaesthesia, is an alternative. It is associated with less maternal hypotension [20], although it remains to be seen whether it causes less fetal acidosis. When there is fetal compromise and spinal anaesthesia is considered the best option under the circumstance, it is important to take steps to minimise the potential for fetal acidosis. In such situations, my practice is to use a prophylactic phenylephrine infusion started immediately after the spinal injection and adjusted to maintain baseline systolic blood pressure [21], to administer glycopyrronium if the heart rate falls below 80 beat.min−1, take meticulous care with maternal posture utilising the left lateral position to minimise aortocaval compression while establishing the block, and administer oxygen to the mother until after delivery. Since the advent of small gauge atraumatic needles, spinals have served us well in obstetrics and have allowed us to offer safe regional anaesthesia for Caesarean delivery in most situations where previously general anaesthesia was used. It is not so much a case of abandoning spinal anaesthesia for the compromised fetus as being cleverer in its selection and application.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Paul Clyburn (2005) conducted an editorial in Caesarean section. Spinal anaesthesia vs. General or epidural anaesthesia was evaluated on Neonatal umbilical cord blood pH (average reduction 0.015). Spinal anaesthesia for Caesarean section is associated with a small reduction in neonatal umbilical cord blood pH compared to general or epidural anaesthesia.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: