Key result
General anaesthesia for emergency caesarean delivery was associated with a higher incidence of Apgar scores <7 at five minutes and higher intensive care admission.
Why the study?
Does general anaesthesia worsen neonatal outcomes compared to regional anaesthesia in emergency caesarean delivery for fetal distress?
Does general anaesthesia worsen neonatal outcomes compared to regional anaesthesia in emergency caesarean delivery for fetal distress?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While general anaesthesia for emergency caesarean delivery is faster, it is associated with poorer neonatal outcomes, highlighting the need to carefully weigh risks and benefits.
In this issue of ANZJOG, Beckmann and Calderbank1 present the results of a retrospective study of neonatal outcomes in 533 babies after either general (n = 81) or regional (n = 452) anaesthesia for emergency caesarean delivery for fetal distress at the Mater Health Services, Brisbane. They demonstrated that whilst the decision to delivery interval was shorter with the use of general anaesthesia (25 vs 33 min), there was a higher incidence of depressed Apgar scores at five minutes, more intensive resuscitation requirements and more admissions to a neonatal intensive care unit. Whilst the authors acknowledge that selection bias may contribute to some of the findings and that the association does not necessarily mean causation, the findings are plausible given our current understanding of the effects of general anaesthesia on the fetus and should lead us to ask whether the time saved by performing a general anaesthetic is in the best interests of the baby. When faced with a request to provide anaesthesia for caesarean delivery the anaesthetist has essentially three options available. These are either general anaesthesia, spinal anaesthesia or ‘topping up’ an existing epidural catheter. Whilst superficially it may appear a relatively easy decision for the anaesthetist to make, the reality is more complex. Each technique has relative risks and benefits for both the mother and the fetus.2 Some techniques are of higher risk in certain situations (eg general anaesthesia in the morbidly obese parturient), and some techniques are relatively contraindicated in selected maternal states (eg regional anaesthesia in the setting of severe maternal haemorrhage or coagulopathy). Historically, general anaesthesia was the primary technique used for caesarean delivery but fell out of favour after the reporting of a large number of anaesthesia-related maternal deaths associated with failed oxygenation and/or aspiration. Whilst there have been a number of advances in regional anaesthesia, general anaesthesia has also undoubtedly become much safer secondary to factors such as better equipment available for airway management, the teaching of algorithms for difficult airway management and more advanced training and monitoring. Whereas general anaesthesia used to have a much higher maternal mortality than regional anaesthesia,3 recent data suggest that the mortality is similar between groups.4 However, opting to proceed with general anaesthesia for caesarean delivery is not a decision to be taken lightly: maternal mortality reports still contain cases of preventable deaths as a result of general anaesthesia for caesarean delivery.5, 6 Obstetric patients are thought to have higher rates of difficult and failed intubation compared to the nonpregnant population.7 This, in conjunction with the decreased exposure to obstetric general anaesthesia, the emergency nature of many cases and their occurrence in the after-hours period when more junior staff are involved, adds to the risk for the mother.8, 9 When faced with an emergency caesarean delivery for fetal distress, speed is often (and perhaps incorrectly) considered the key priority. In this situation, the focus of the obstetric and midwifery teams often shifts to the well-being of the fetus as the primary concern, with the anaesthetist becoming the key advocate for the safety of both the mother and fetus. In terms of speed of delivery, when the decision to delivery interval is examined, general anaesthesia has been shown to be marginally quicker using a functioning in situ epidural catheter and considerably quicker than the institution of a new regional block. Australian data from the Royal Women's Hospital in Melbourne showed an average decision to delivery interval for ‘Code’ caesareans of 17, 19 and 26 min for general, epidural and spinal anaesthesia, respectively.10 This is in keeping with the data from Beckmann and Calderbank where the respective times were 25 min for general anaesthesia and 33 min for regional anaesthesia (which included both epidural and spinal anaesthesia). The knowledge that only a relatively small difference in delivery to decision interval exists between general and epidural anaesthesia forms part of the rationale behind the recommendation to place epidural catheters in high-risk women during labour thus potentially avoiding the risks of a general anaesthetic.11 This approach is taken most commonly in the morbidly obese woman, for whom the rapid institution of general anaesthesia is fraught with difficulties12 but is also appropriate in women who are at risk of having a ‘difficult airway’ or for those with underlying cardiac conditions where general anaesthesia may cause a catastrophic loss of vital organ perfusion. Whilst there has been a large amount of information published about the risks and benefits of the various modes of anaesthesia for the mother, the fetus and neonate have not received the same degree of attention in recent years. With the large shift away from the use of general anaesthesia, randomised controlled trials in this area are now very difficult to conduct, and instead, contemporary knowledge comes largely from prospective or retrospective studies, such as those of Beckmann and Calderbank. Despite the limitations of these study designs, there are still very valid reasons why general anaesthesia can be associated with poorer neonatal outcomes and a number of lessons that can be learned from their data. First, a number of the drugs used in general anaesthesia, particularly induction agents, opioids and volatile anaesthetics, cross the placenta and exert similar cardiorespiratory depressant effects as demonstrable in the mother.13 Beckmann and Calderbank demonstrate the need for more intensive resuscitation of these babies, who have lower Apgar scores (<7) at five minutes (7.4 vs 1.8%) and a greater need for respiratory support (27.4 vs 13.5%). The person responsible for neonatal resuscitation will potentially be required to manage a more compromised neonate and, additional assistance may be needed. Second, the number of babies that required admission to an intensive care nursery was higher in the general anaesthesia cohort (OR 2.46). It is commonly assumed that the effects of general anaesthesia on the neonate will be short-lived, but the selection bias aside, the potential implications of a significantly higher intensive care admission rate deserve consideration. Finally, the umbilical arterial pH of babies born by general anaesthesia was lower than babies born by regional anaesthesia (7.211 vs 7.240). Whilst again it may be argued that this is secondary to selection bias and unlikely to be clinically significant, it is in keeping with our emerging knowledge of the effects of different modes of anaesthesia on neonatal acid–base balance.14, 15 In addition to the early placement of epidural catheters in high-risk women in labour, what else can be performed to minimise the likelihood of using general anaesthesia and buy the time required for the anaesthetist to institute an effective regional block in an emergency situation? The distressed fetus may benefit from ‘in utero’ resuscitation measures and optimisation of placental perfusion.16 These measures include minimising aortocaval compression (by the use of lateral tilt, manual uterine compression or a full lateral position) and the correction of maternal hypotension. Fluid administration is commonly recommended for maternal hypotension, but the maternal response to this is likely to be slow when compared to the titration of a vasopressor drug; hence, the anaesthetist should be contacted for advice and assistance immediately. Any increase in uterine tone can worsen placental perfusion, so uterotonic infusions should be ceased immediately, and tocolytics administered if indicated. Finally, the maternal administration of oxygen, whilst controversial, must also be considered. Should the findings of Beckmann and Calderbank lead to the avoidance of general anaesthesia even in the severely compromised fetus? We think not, as in many situations, general anaesthesia will still be required, and lengthy delay whilst trying to achieve regional anaesthesia may potentially lead to poorer outcomes. However, their findings should reinforce the message that requesting the anaesthetist to perform general anaesthesia, without full understanding of the risks for both the mother and her baby, is inappropriate and that good teamwork and communication between the obstetrician, midwife, anaesthetist and paediatrician is essential for the optimisation of outcomes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
McDonnell et al. (2012) conducted an editorial in Emergency caesarean delivery for fetal distress (n=533). General anaesthesia vs. Regional anaesthesia was evaluated on Apgar scores <7 at five minutes. General anaesthesia for emergency caesarean delivery was associated with a higher incidence of Apgar scores <7 at five minutes and higher intensive care admission.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: