Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A key argument in Agricultural Involution concerns the relationship between rice and sugar cultivation. In Geertz's view the irrigation systems which accompanied the export sugar economy increased both the extent and the fertility of the sawah and made it possible for the Javanese to raise rice yields through evermore labor intensive methods. This claim is misleading because it overemphasizes the agronomic similarities between sugar and rice, and ignores the ways in which estate sugar cultivation constrained labor intensification in subsistence rice farming. During the past fifteen years the interpretation of Javanese colonial history has been dominated by a single book: Clifford Geertz's Agricultural Involution (1963). In less than 200 pages this justly acclaimed study discusses 120 years of Javanese history and confronts many of the important theoretical issues in Javanese historiography. But despite, or perhaps because of its paramount position, Agricultural Involution has received little critical attention. Most reviews have been laudatory (Benda 1966; Conklin 1968; Jaspan 1965; Koentjaraningrat 1975:202-204; Larking 1971; Missen 1972; Mubyarto 1978; Sajogoy 1976:xxi-xxxi; Sharma 1964; Smail 1965; Wertheim 1964; Yengoyan 1966) and with one exception (White 1973; 1976) no one has subsantially challenged or modified any key part of its argument. Geertz's critics (e.g., Utrecht 1973; Hinkson 1975) have concentrated on his description of the village economy-arguing that he overstates the extent of economic homogeneity and that there is little evidence of the rich forgoing income in the interests of the poor. Lyon (1970), in the most comprehensive critique to date, claims that there was increasing social and economic polarization in rural Java during the colonial period and castigates the static equilibrium assumptions she discerns in Geertz's work. ETHNOHISTORY 25/3 (Summer 1978) 207 This content downloaded from 157.55.39.243 on Wed, 05 Oct 2016 04:41:33 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms 208 JENNIFER and PAUL ALEXANDER The absence of theoretically based criticism is surprising in view of the growth of interest in both cultural ecology and peasant societies during the past decade. There have also been a large number of field studies by demographers, economists and anthropologists which can be used to correct any tendency to treat Geertz's fieldsite in East Java, Modjokuto, as a microcosm of Javanese society. Agricultural Involution was in many respects a pioneer study and it would be remarkable if its analysis could stand unaltered in the face of more recent fieldwork and general theoretical developments within anthropology. The Mutualistic Relationship Between Sugar and Rice Agricultural Involution represents the development of labor-intensive sawah agriculture as a defensive attempt by a traditional society to cope with the twin demands of a rapidly increasing population and export-orientated agriculture controlled by the colonial power. When Dutch actions lowered mortality rates after 1830, the burden of maintaining the increased population fell upon the subsistence sector. Unable to control population growth, the Javanese took advantage of the inherent labor elasticity of the sawah ecosystem to develop a very labor-intensive form of agriculture and, in the institutions labeled shared poverty, an equitable means of sharing the product. A key argument in this thesis is the bond between sugar and rice cultivation. Sugar demands irrigation (and drainage) and a general environment almost identical to that for wet rice; thus, it was almost of necessity initially cultivated on peasant sawah. . . (1963:55) In the mutualistic relationship, the expansion of one side, sugar cultivation, brings with it the expansion of the other, wet-rice growing. The more numerous and the better irrigated the terraces are, the more sugar can be grown; and the more people a seasonal, readily available, resident labor force (a sort of part-time proletariat) supported by these terraces during the nonsugar portion of the cycle, can grow sugar (1963:56-57). Geertz argues that it was the increase in both the extent and the fertility of the sawah caused by the development of sugar cultivation, which made it possible for the Javanese to raise sawah productivity by evermore labor intensive methods of cultivation. Reviewers appeared to regard this aspect of Agricultural Involution as very grounded (Yengoyan 1966; Missen 1972), and on the basis of the Javanese material alone this opinion seems justified. There are some apparent anomalies, however, when Javanese rice farming is compared with wet rice cultivation in other Asian countries. The abundant supplies of labor and This content downloaded from 157.55.39.243 on Wed, 05 Oct 2016 04:41:33 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms Sugar, Rice and Irrigation in Colonial Java 209 expertly developed terraces suggest that the productivity of Javanese rice cultivation should be high by Asian standards. Yet, as Geertz (1963:131) himself notes, Japanese rice yields which were similar to Java's in 1868, were 250 percent greater by 1960. Rejecting an explanation based on the technical superiority of Japanese agriculture, on the grounds that this is part of the phenomenon to be explained, he argues that the critical factor was the demographic history of the two countries. Because Japanese population growth was absorbed in the industrial sector, Japanese farmers could concentrate solely on raising productivity per hectare and they accomplished this by raising the productivity of each agricultural worker through higher capital inputs, especially fertilizer. Javanese farmers, on the other hand, were forced to provide work for the growing rural population and this hampered attempts to raise the productivity of land. But while it is true that Japanese rice farming is more capital-intensive and gives greater yields per agricultural worker than Java's, it is not the case that Javanese agriculture is more labor-intensive. Despite greater mechanization, Japanese cultivators use only slightly fewer man hours per hectare in growing a single rice crop and obtain higher yields.1 On an annual basis, Japanese agriculture is more labor-intensive: the high yields are not merely a product of greater capitalization, they are also due to the Japanese farmers' ability to maximize land use by utilizing high labor inputs throughout the year (Collier 1977; Stoler 1977). Nor is Japan unique: in other high yielding wet rice systems in Bengal and Taiwan, the high labor inputs made possible by multiple cropping are crucial in obtaining high levels of production.2 The knowledge that neither the labor intensity nor the annual yield of Javanese rice farming is high by Asian standards, suggests that Geertz's description of the relationship between sugar and rice cultivation as mutualistic, might be reconsidered. While we do not dispute Geertz's claim that sugar cultivation played the major role in extending the area of sawah available for rice cultivation, we argue that it also imposed severe limits on the Javanese peasants' ability to lift the productivity of their sawah through greater labor inputs. In other words, while Geertz's description of positive feedback in the sawah ecosystem is correct, he neglected the constraints imposed through negative feedback.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alexander et al. (1978) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: