Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Rate constants for gas-phase proton transfer to Mn(CO)5 −, Re(CO)6 − and Cl− from reference acids and metal hydrides are determined. Proton-transfer efficiencies to Mn(CO)5 − are small, and less than the efficiencies for proton transfer to Cl−; proton-transfer efficiencies to Re(CO)6 − are larger than those for Mn(CO)5 −, but still generally less than for transfer to Cl−. Proton-transfer efficiencies to Mn(CO)5 − and Re(CO)5 − are substantially more dependent on the nature of the proton donor (e.g. metal hydride versus oxy-acid). The thermoneutral proton transfer between Mn(CO)5 − and 13CO-labelled HMn(CO)6 is particularly inefficient, occurring only in about 1 in 100 collisions. The results are discussed in view of evidence for a short lifetime of the collision complex, and the effects of electronic and structural reorganization of Mn(CO)5 − and Re(CO)5 −, including loss of fluxionality of the metal species, which occur on protonation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Miller et al. (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: