Key result
The Coaguchek monitor was superior to the ProTime system in clinical correlation, with fewer INRs resulting in a different therapeutic decision compared to standard lab testing.
Why the study?
Do handheld prothrombin time monitoring devices (Coaguchek and ProTime) provide accurate and clinically correlated INR values compared to standard laboratory methods in ambulatory patients?
Observational
Do handheld prothrombin time monitoring devices (Coaguchek and ProTime) provide accurate and clinically correlated INR values compared to standard laboratory methods in ambulatory patients?
The Coaguchek handheld monitor provides superior accuracy and clinical correlation compared to the ProTime system for INR monitoring, and patients strongly prefer the finger stick method over venipuncture.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May inform point-of-care INR device selection in ambulatory care; hypothesis-generating and requires prospective validation before practice change.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy, clinical correlation, ease of use, and patient acceptance of the Coaguchek and the ProTime Microcoagulation System as compared with standard laboratory methods for prothrombin time determination. METHODS: A total of 30 prothrombin times, expressed as international normalized ratios (INRs), were determined by each handheld device for comparison with standard laboratory testing. Accuracy was evaluated by calculating the absolute difference for each pair of INR values. Clinical correlation was defined as an INR obtained by the handheld monitor that would have resulted in the same therapeutic decision as the INR obtained by the standard laboratory method. Subjects were surveyed to determine which method of INR determination they preferred and their reasons for that preference. RESULTS: Accuracy was superior with the Coaguchek monitor. The absolute difference (mean +/- SD) in the laboratory and Coaguchek INRs was 0.28+/-0.23 (p = 0.96). The absolute difference (mean +/- SD) in the laboratory and the ProTime Microcoagulation System INRs was 0.56+/-0.34 (p < 0.001). For clinical correlation, two out of 24 (8.3%) INRs with the Coaguchek were sufficiently different from the laboratory INR to have resulted in a different therapeutic decision, compared with 12 out of 24 (50%) with the ProTime Microcoagulation System (p < 0.005). Of subjects surveyed, 77.8% preferred the finger stick method. CONCLUSIONS: The Coaguchek was superior to the ProTime Microcoagulation System in accuracy, clinical correlation, and ease of use. The study also showed that patients preferred capillary blood sampling by finger puncture over venipuncture for INR monitoring.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chapman et al. (1999) conducted an observational in Patients requiring prothrombin time monitoring. Coaguchek monitor vs. ProTime Microcoagulation System was evaluated on INRs resulting in a different therapeutic decision compared to standard laboratory method (p=<0.005). The Coaguchek monitor was superior to the ProTime system in clinical correlation, with fewer INRs resulting in a different therapeutic decision compared to standard lab testing.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: