Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Despite the potential contribution suggested from chromatographic studies of many groups, taxonomic conclusions based on paper chromatography alone may carry some inherent errors. In many instances chemical differences between taxa cannot be characterized by two‐dimensional chromatography of crude extracts. Pigment diversity may go unnoticed in such a study, and conclusions based on simple chromatographic results may show too much similarity between the taxa being compared. The resolution of chromatographic separations of the often very complex mixtures encountered in crude plant extracts can be greatly improved by a preliminary column separation, and in this study a method of pigment analysis employing both preliminary column and subsequent paper chromatography is used. While it is usually impractical to identify all of the components of a flavonoid complex, each member should be characterized to the degree that it can be distinguished from all others. Here, the characterization of a component includes its rate of movement in the column, relative position and color under ultraviolet light on the chromatogram, the absorption spectrum in ethanol and the change in the absorption spectrum when a reagent is added to the ethanol which has a particular effect on the spectral properties of that flavonoid. With very few exceptions no one criterion of characterization is definitive for any component. More than 20 flavonoid pigments have been observed in the two tetraploid Gossypium species, G. barbadense and G. hirsutum. Only 10 of the constituents were common to the two species. The results of a previous study based on two‐way paper chromatography of crude extracts makes the two species appear much more similar in flavonoid composition than is indicated by the more detailed column‐paper chromatography presented here. The degree of difference between G. hirsutum and G. barbadense is surprisingly large in light of the generally accepted theory of their common origin. The value of chromatographic‐chemotaxonomic studies is greatly increased if the chemical systems involved are characterized.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Clifford R. Parks (1967) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: