Why the study?
Does the introduction of a EWTD-compliant rota reduce the number of solo lists undertaken by anaesthesia trainees?
Does the introduction of a EWTD-compliant rota reduce the number of solo lists undertaken by anaesthesia trainees?
The implementation of EWTD-compliant rotas significantly reduced independent clinical experience (solo lists) for anaesthesia trainees, raising concerns about training completeness.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
EWTD rotas may limit trainee autonomy; leaves open effects on competence and need for compensatory training.
The European Working Time Directive (EWTD) [1] became compulsory for all doctors in training in August 2004. The directive imposes strict limits on the maximum number of hours worked in an average week and specifies maximum continuous duty periods and requisite off-duty periods. Training in anaesthesia was reduced significantly with the introduction of the New Deal [2] and Calman training [3]. The constraints of the EWTD have since raised concerns that the training of anaesthetists may be further compromised. Previous reports have drawn attention to the impact of the EWTD on training [4-7]. A significant reduction in the total number of hours worked and in the number of cases undertaken by trainees was emphasised. The number of solo lists undertaken by Specialist Registrars (SpRs) also decreased by an average of one list per week [4] and the authors of that audit commented that this was important from the perspective of service provision. Indeed, they identified such solo lists as service lists. However, we view these data from a different perspective as we believe that solo lists form an integral and vital aspect of training in anaesthesia. We were concerned that SpRs working in our hospital were not gaining sufficient independent clinical experience during normal working hours. Accordingly, we undertook an audit to assess the impact of the introduction of a EWTD-compliant rota on the training of anaesthetists and in particular its effect on solo lists undertaken by SpRs. Data were obtained by analysis of the departmental rotas for two periods of 1 month, before and after the introduction of the EWTD. Out of hours work in the evenings and at weekends was excluded from the analysis. The working week was divided into 10 sessions available for training and trainees' work patterns were categorised as supervised clinical, solo clinical, CPD activity, annual or sick leave, and compensatory rest period. We found a reduction in the amount of clinical training time available to trainees of approximately 30% after the introduction of the EWTD-compliant rota. The Royal College of Anaesthetists' gold standard of a minimum of three supervised clinical sessions per week was met by all SpRs in both periods of study. However, the number of solo lists undertaken by SpRs fell from 1.63 to 0.38 per week, a 77% reduction. Senior House Officers (SHOs) received the vast majority of their clinical training during supervised sessions, although this fell from an average of 5.6 to 3.9 per week. The results of our audit accord with similar published findings [4-7]. The Royal College of Anaesthetists publishes recommendations for the minimum number of supervised lists that trainees should receive. There is no guidance, however, about independent clinical work. We believe that solo lists undertaken during normal working hours are an important aspect of SpR training. They provide an opportunity to develop organisational capabilities and experience of working with and leading a team. Decision-making about the various aspects of patient care is facilitated. We were, therefore, disappointed to find that implementation of a EWTD-compliant rota has had a deleterious effect. We believe that to ignore this aspect of training will result in incompletely trained anaesthetists and newly appointed consultants may lack confidence. One solution to this problem has been to provide so-called ‘semi-solo’ sessions during which the trainee is required to undertake the list as if working alone but with a consultant on hand who is not required for other duties immediately available for advice and assistance as needed. However, successful implementation of this scheme has been hampered by the conflicting demands of training and service provision and there is often pressure for the consultant to ‘intervene’ to facilitate a rapid turnover of cases.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bhadra et al. (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: