Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The reduction in clinical training time and case numbers for anaesthetic trainees in the UK raises concerns about the adequacy of current postgraduate medical education structures.
In 1993, Calman proposed changes to medical training that included reducing the training time for a consultant anaesthetist to six years 1. Since then, we have seen the formation and demise of the Postgraduate Medical Education and Training Board and the Deaneries. The failings of the Modernising Medical Careers program were laid bare in the 2008 Tooke report 2. More recently, Health Education England was involved with a junior doctor contract that triggered industrial action, and it oversees a national recruitment process that fails to recruit to many training posts. During this time, there has been no meaningful reduction in the number of years it takes to train to become an anaesthetic consultant. This warrants consideration of how current postgraduate education is structured, and why it fails to achieve the key Calman objective of shorter training. In the UK, in 1990, a variety of working patterns existed for anaesthetists in training. Anaesthetic rotas typically had between three and five trainees, and most trainees were resident when on duty. A common four-person rota involved trainees working an average of one 24-h shift and two 10-h shifts in four days (Table 1), equivalent to about 77 h per week. Career progression depended on consultant posts being filled from the senior registrar pool, leading to promotions for established registrars and senior house officers (SHO). Novices were then recruited to the SHO grade. Specialist anaesthetic training typically took between seven and eight years 3. A small, personal, retrospective audit of training experience of consultants appointed in 1990 found that anaesthetic trainees typically completed about 1000 procedures every year (range 800–1400), with many cases performed on service lists. Trainees typically performed over 7000 anaesthetics before becoming a consultant. By 1999, there had already been a significant reduction in case numbers performed by trainees to an average of less than 500 cases per year, with a trend for further falls since then 4-6. Between 1999 and 2009, the number of midweek lists completed by speciality trainees fell, in some studies by about 20%, and most of this decline was in solo service lists 5-7. The marked drop in case numbers that has occurred since 1990 is easily overlooked, as many studies only consider outcomes after 1999. In 2017, many units are larger than in 1990 7, rotas contain more trainees, and as the number of trainees on each rota has increased, the number of nights and weekends worked by individuals has fallen. Hours are now limited to 48 per week 8, and career progression is time-constrained, with core training (CT) posts taking at least two years and specialist trainee registrar posts five years or more. Trainees now often achieve their certificate of completion of training (CCT) having performed fewer than 3500 anaesthetics (audit of peri-CCT trainees at the GAT consultant interview seminar 18/10/2016; excludes dual ITU/anaesthesia and overseas trainees). Today, a newly-appointed consultant has performed a similar number of cases as a 1990 third-year registrar. Can changes in anaesthetic training compensate for such a large fall in case numbers? “Learn to see, learn to hear, learn to feel, learn to smell, and know that by practice alone you can become expert.” William Osler (1849–1919). In the 19th century, William Osler regularly highlighted the importance of the clinical exposure that underpins medical education. His view is now supported by evidence that deliberate practice during clinical contact time with patients is pivotal for learning in postgraduate medical training 9-12, and the skills that can be achieved during training are related to the time allowed for this. Deliberate practice is maximised by good quality feedback, and training that maximises input from trainers during clinical time is vital for the development of skills. So, to deliver medical training efficiently and effectively, we should maximise supervised clinical training time. This needs to be enhanced with non-clinical teaching and assessment, but non-clinical activity should be delivered in a way that does not disrupt the clinical component of training. To compare clinical training time in 1990 with today we need a reference point. If we assume that in 1990 a trainee working on a four-person rota potentially had 120 midweek training days, and worked about 90 night shifts and 26 weekend long day shifts each year (Table 1), we can compare that with current rota models. Throughout the UK, weekend and night activities in operating theatres, labour ward and intensive care are not less than in 1990 (and are probably greater), but the total number of trainees working those shifts is similar. Studies support the hypothesis that change from the old ‘on-call’ to the new shift work patterns has not led to a material change in total out-of-hours caseload 4. In today's full-shift rotas, most of the reduction in total working hours has been achieved because trainees work more intensively (but for fewer nights), and has the advantage that patient care is being delivered by less tired doctors. The bulk of the reduction in case numbers is because fewer cases are being performed in daytime, leading to fewer consultant-supervised cases on training lists. A number of factors influence how much consultant-supervised training time is available. If European Working Time Directive (EWTD) regulations are adopted with an average maximum 48-h week (four weeks of annual leave, eight bank holidays and no study leave), then midweek clinical training time on a 1 in 8 rota could increase (Table 1). However, in 2002 and 2016, new junior doctor's contracts were introduced. They also commit trainees to an average of up to 48 h of work each week, but with up to six weeks annual leave, two statutory days, eight bank holidays and 30 days of study leave. We know from modelling and experience that with these contracts that a full-shift rota needs about 10 doctors to maintain midweek training opportunities close to 1990 levels (Table 1). Increasing a rota to more than 10 trainees provides marginal gains in clinical training time, but if an establishment drops below eight doctors, midweek training opportunities rapidly decline (Table 1). For training rotas with eight or fewer doctors, we need other arrangements to maintain consultant-supervised clinical training time, such as resident consultants at weekends undertaking training lists. However, units that have introduced rotas with 9 or 10 trainees still have problems delivering clinical training time. Recruitment to anaesthesia by Health Education England at specialist trainee level fell to 90% in 2016, leaving many training posts unfilled. There were also predictable gaps due to long-term sickness, trainees sent on secondments to other training units, and others leaving training posts to take up consultant and other appointments. As well as reducing the number of people in a rota, gaps increase out-of-hours and service activity for the remaining trainees, and reduce their availability for midweek clinical training. From August 2017, the 2016 Junior Doctors’ Contract has been introduced to anaesthetic training 13. It only commits to a 40-h working week, with additional hours of paid work at the discretion of the trust. There is potential for loss of clinical training time to cut costs. Some training initiatives have also removed trainees from the clinical environment. For example, a recommendation for 4 h of classroom teaching every week potentially removes 20% of available midweek clinical training time. Other educational initiatives such as journal club, morbidity and mortality meetings, and clinical governance meetings, may also reduce clinical training time. Induction, statutory and mandatory training may only take a couple of days in each hospital, but with 6-month attachments this removes four days a year from clinical training. Even safety measures such as the WHO checklist have the capacity to reduce clinical training time. Other initiatives may be delivered inefficiently, for example, the annual review of competence progression (ARCP) only takes half an hour, but if the trainee must travel to attend the ARCP it may cost half a day of clinical training time. Covering gaps, induction and statutory training, audit, journal club, morbidity and mortality meetings, statutory leave (such as paternity leave and jury service) also have the capacity to reduce training time. Each activity, even if it occurs infrequently or involves just few trainees, may only trim a few training hours and may, in isolation appear inconsequential. But the combined effect is that a large proportion of the potential clinical training time is lost. The increase in non-clinical training initiatives has progressively eroded clinical training time, inefficient delivery has the capacity to make it worse, and clinical training time is often only a fraction of what it could be. Can such a large loss of clinical training time be compensated for by improvements in the quality and nature of training? In 1990, assessment of competence was less structured than today. It was based on local assessments, the Diploma in Anaesthesia and other examinations, and job interviews. Some clinical experience was on dedicated training lists, but the degree of supervision of these lists was quite variable, and training could also be very variable between units. On reflection, there is an impression that inappropriate cases were occasionally being managed by trainees. Training today has more structure, with more formal assessment of competencies to guide progression, which were introduced in an attempt to address failures of more traditional approaches to training 14. Workplace-based assessments (WPBA) are largely used to assess skills and competencies, and there is some evidence that this approach can improve performance and safety 15, 16. Multi-source feedback from colleagues and patients is thought by many to be a reliable and useful method of assessing workplace performance 17. However, they can only be appropriate and effective when they are based on, and used to assess, clinical activity. They are built on behaviourist theories of education, where evidence for skills is based on breaking down skills into behaviours that may be objectively measured. This approach is suited for simple tasks, but may not be suitable to assess the high-level skills also required of a healthcare professional operating in a highly complex environment. It is difficult to encapsulate the knowledge and skills required for a role in a necessarily limited set of competencies 18, 19, and high-functioning trainees may not be easy to identify in a system that is based on baseline competencies. The gap between competency assessments and what is actually required in terms of training outcomes is complex 20, and overlaps with ideas of expertise. Terms such as Entrustable Professional Activities and Statements of Awarded Responsibility have been used to bridge this gap 21. It is likely that most postgraduate training programmes have such elements, though they are not always explicitly recognised or stated. The assessments may themselves also be prone to bias, and depend on the skills and variety of assessors. The potential for local variation in training cannot therefore be completely eliminated by the introduction of a competency-based assessment structure, even though the method of assessment is transparent. The focus on competencies gained (rather than time served) is an important concept which underpins the nature of postgraduate education in the UK, but duration of training is still regarded as critical and is required by all the UK Royal Colleges. If individuals have not achieved the necessary competencies, then time for training is prolonged, but is never shortened if competencies are achieved earlier. Other changes, such as the type of training outside the clinical environment, also deserves consideration. Training for emergencies and human factors in simulated environments is now a common feature of anaesthetic training. There is good evidence from surgical training that such techniques are extremely effective when followed by clinical practice 22. However, there is also evidence that if simulation training is not reinforced by practice in the clinical environment, these skills deteriorate in weeks or months 23. The success of simulation training depends upon practice in the clinical environment. Simulation training is a useful supplement to clinical training, enabling trainees to practice human factors and other skills without risking patient harm. It may enhance clinical training, but is not a substitute for it. One of the objectives of the Calman Report 1 was to deliver anaesthetic training in six years, but the training program is at least seven years, and training takes an average of between eight and nine years 24. The changes in supervision and other training techniques that have been introduced in recent years have not enabled a reduction in training time, but clinical contact time as a proportion of training has reduced. There are almost no published standards for the minimum amount of clinical time required to adequately support modern competency-based training. The Royal College of Anaesthetists proposed a minimum weekly average of 15 h of consultant-supervised training to progress through training 25, equivalent to 156 half-day lists a year. However, this standard was opinion-based, poorly evidenced, poorly defined and is rarely assessed. If this standard is not achieved it is not an impediment to progression through training, nor does failure to deliver it result in censure of training departments. It also does not recommend a minimum volume of total clinical time, and has the potential to become the maximum amount of clinical training rather than a minimum. The lack of clear targets, objective measurement and penalties for failure devalues the importance of clinical time in training. We need to recognise that time spent in the clinical environment is the most important aspect of medical training, and that it needs to be protected. There is an argument that more clinical time in isolation may be of little benefit to training, but without time spent in the clinical environment the techniques that support training lose their value. It is therefore important to focus on maximising clinical time, as only by doing this can the full benefits of modern teaching techniques, such as WPBAs, be realised. Training activities outside the clinical environment need to be delivered efficiently to maximise their benefits to training, and the challenge for trainers is to provide this support without reducing clinical time. Doing this may allow us to achieve the Calman target of a six-year training program 26. Service reconfiguration may help; Paul et al. 7 described a 70% increase in case numbers by anaesthetic core trainees following a series of service reconfigurations, which also led to a reduction in the need for external study leave. But service reconfiguration will only give benefits if we have fully staffed training rotas. We know from experience that a full-shift training rota needs an establishment of at least nine trainees to deliver sufficient midweek clinical time to reliably achieve 15 h per week of consultant-supervised training. Where training rotas fall below nine trainees we should adopt other training patterns, which could include resident consultants providing supervised training at weekends or at night. Perhaps the best way to structure training is to have fewer full-shift rotas, but ensure that each has sufficient lines for training, and always keep these rotas fully staffed. The 2016 contract clarifies that all non-clinical training, except induction and statutory training, should be taken from the study leave allowance 13. To maximise the benefits of non-clinical training, the components of study leave should be formally assessed and not be mandated where there is no evidence of benefit. Improved delivery could be achieved by, for example, replacing formal training days with an online training program and performing the ARCP in a trainee's base hospital to reduce travelling time. A standard national ‘Statutory Training Program’ delivered online and transferrable between hospitals could reduce hospital and department induction to less than a day, and local teaching planned for the morning before clinical activities start could allow both to happen unimpeded. To facilitate the efficient progression through training we should adopt and measure clearly defined, objective targets for the minimum amount of clinical time required. ‘Fifteen hours per week of consultant-supervised training’ should be defined as ‘to progress, a full-time trainee must always have completed a mean of 780 h per year of direct consultant-supervised clinical training’. This would allow more supervised training to take place in the formative core trainee years, while allowing more independent practice as trainees approach their CCT. Postgraduate curricular changes are complex and time consuming 26, but supervised clinical time should be the foundation for learning in all healthcare specialities. Clinical hours worked each year should be matched with appropriate supervision and training. Assessment of clinical training should be objective, include a responsibility for ensuring compliance with statutory training, and be ensured by the annual ARCP. This should also be the point at which a trainee's clinical, statutory and other training records are reviewed and recorded. These objective data could then be used to provide training assessments for individual trainees, and would allow valid comparisons between trainees, departments and regions. Analysis of these figures could then be used to help improve training in departments, allow validation of the benefit of any new training initiatives and guide future training. To achieve this, trainees should be asked to objectively record both their training hours and what they learnt on that shift. Electronic rota systems are extensively used in UK anaesthetic departments, and they could help to rapidly produce credible and timely information on training, as described elsewhere in this issue 27. This could replace the General Medical Council training survey 14, which is a poor assessment tool. It asks subjective questions (e.g. ‘During an average month how many times were you moved from a training list to provide service cover?’); the response bands are too wide (e.g. ‘missing between 1 and 4 training lists per month’ is between 12 and 48 list per year); and makes no reference to rota size. Losing 12 training lists on a 10-person rota is of little consequence, but losing 48 training lists on a 1 in 8 rota is significant. Its results are difficult to interpret on an individual, local, regional and national level. The repeated re-organisation of the bodies that oversee training have created many challenges for trainers and trainees. A major casualty of this reorganisation has been clinical contact time, and proposed future changes seem likely to reduce it further. Clinical time is only one aspect of training, but it is fundamental to future practice. Setting objectives for the amount of clinical time required to complete training and formal recording of objective measurements of this seems a sensible first step. BJ is an Editor of Anaesthesia. No other competing interests declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
England et al. (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: