Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Less than full-time training in anaesthesia retains doctors in the workforce and does not act as a barrier to successful completion of training.
In their article in this issue of Anaesthesia 1, Randive et al. explore the impact of less than full-time (LTFT) working on training time and career progression after obtaining a Certificate of Completion of Training (CCT), by using data from two databases of the Royal College of Anaesthetists (RCoA). Their data add to the authors’ recently published preliminary report 2. They explore time spent in LTFT compared with full-time training, achievement of a CCT and the type of consultant post to which trainees were appointed. Their data successfully dispel the myth that LTFT doubles training time and lessens the number of CCT holders. It also fails to support the perception that LTFT means that fewer anaesthetists are trained to meet demand; this is only equivalent to the loss of one whole-time equivalent per year nationally. Their message is clear: LTFT retains doctors in the workforce and is no barrier to successful completion of training. It would have been useful to know the reasons for LTFT training. Whilst women make up the majority, it is not clear how many had caring responsibilities or health issues and are successfully supported to complete training. There are other unanswered questions thrown up by this article; for example: what has happened to the 441 trainees who obtained a CCT but have not yet been recorded as obtaining a consultant post? And whilst most LTFT trainees go on to full-time consultant posts, is this because part-time posts were not available? Approximately 11% of all UK trainees (Foundation and Speciality) work LTFT for at least part of their training programme. The percentage varies by specialty, with more in medicine, paediatrics, anaesthetics and general practice, and fewer in surgical specialties 3. Anaesthesia has led the way by introducing a variety of working patterns to promote retention. Over 20 years ago, the RCoA acknowledged the need to provide high-quality, pro-rata training for those trainees who worked part time by establishing the role of Bernard Johnson Advisor. This role is to support LTFT trainees, set strategy for LTFT training, promote best practice for LTFT and ensure that issues affecting this group of trainees are considered via the RCoA training Committee 4. There is no ‘one size fits all’ training pathway, and anaesthetic LTFT advisors in each training programme and region of the UK work within a local framework, acting as sources of information and expertise to promote and develop LTFT within their own specialty training programme. This enables the advisors to use their own experience and knowledge to promote those ways of working that best suit the specialty and location 5. The additional career and psychosocial benefits to LTFT trainees provided by the expertise and support of these consultant advisors should develop and promote their own career and organisational commitment 6. Historically, requests for LTFT training were met by placing the trainees in supernumerary (additional) posts, but the growth in demand meant that new solutions had to found. In 2005, the British Medical Association (BMA), Departments of Health and the Conference of Postgraduate Medical Deans reached an agreement 7 to ensure that all eligible applicants for LTFT training were treated positively. This was to be achieved by greater use of sharing training slots (more than one doctor occupying a training post), reduced-hour working in previously full-time posts, and the creation of supernumerary posts only when the first two options were not possible. In a survey on managing flexible working 8, 90% of the human resources respondents indicated that ‘work-life balance was high on the agenda for a lot of their workforce’, yet felt it was a challenge to fit part-time doctors into a computer-defined rota for full-time workers to meet the European Work Time Regulations. Current intake to medical schools is 65% female, and women, who statistically are more likely to apply for LTFT training 3, will be the majority of doctors by 2017 9. All doctors who wish to train LTFT must be eligible – the majority are those with carers’ responsibilities, but there are also some with acute or chronic health problems and those with other demands on their time e.g. sports or representative roles. Doctors with health issues are enabled to remain in the workforce with appropriate adjustments to their work pattern. This is a growing demand as more students with known disabilities graduate. The acceptance of a growing number of part-time workers has been embraced and promoted by the leadership of the medical profession in such organisations as the BMA and the Medical Royal Colleges 10-13. In 2007, the introduction of new selection processes compliant with equality and diversity legislation 14 increased the numbers of LTFT trainees appointed in the UK. For the first time, appointment panels were not informed of applicants’ wish to work part time before appointment 15. The Medical Schools Council 16 requires medical students to be selected for their ability to become a good doctor, a unique combination of attitudes and attributes that meet the requirements of the General Medical Council 17. Doctors are high achievers, altruistic with a sense of duty, and many are perfectionists. The roles of doctor and mother both require caring and empathy, and so have the potential to generate conflicting demands. Motherhood traditionally places the care of children before self and interests outside the home; medicine has traditionally placed care of patients before care of self. Trainees are culturalised in the beliefs of a profession that traditionally has full-time workers, and may experience conflicting demands when faced with balancing professional and family life 18, and requesting part-time work 19. Balance may not be achievable in roles of both mother and doctor, and there is an inevitable tension caused by the duality of roles 20. Doctors with children have higher career satisfaction 21, yet role conflict increases stress 22, as does working shifts at nights and weekends 23. Published literature on the careers of women doctors usually consists of survey-based quantitative analyses, drawing inference from predetermined questions 24-27. Variation in career structures and terminology of medical grades across the globe make international comparisons difficult, yet all make recommendations to support the careers and working lives of women doctors, including part-time working, working days that accommodate family demands, visible role models, a supportive spouse and access to reliable childcare 28, 29. Role models, senior doctors combining motherhood and a professional career, are important 26, 30, providing clear evidence that the trainees’ chosen career path is possible. Trainees without role models or senior women colleagues may face difficulties requesting part-time working or taking breaks from training 25, 31, 32. The literature describes the impact of motherhood on doctors’ careers. In the 1950s and 1960s, women doctors left work when their children were young, or delayed childbearing until their careers were established, and a significant proportion remained childless 33. Until the 1980s, women doctors took very little maternity leave 30. Whilst still the norm in the USA, women in Europe have access to longer periods of maternity leave and part-time working owing to legislative changes. In Japan, women doctors are expected to leave their careers once they have children 34. The value of LTFT training in retaining trainees in the specialty and enabling them to achieve CCT is supported by these latest data. The specialty of anaesthesia can promote itself as ‘family-friendly’ during recruitment exercises and career promotion events. Trainees can also use this information when speaking to medical students about career choices. Most advertised consultant posts are for full-time employees, whilst stating that applications from those wishing to work part-time are encouraged. The option for part-time work is something that many trainees would not be comfortable exploring whilst seeking a permanent appointment. Employers are encouraged to develop part-time job descriptions to support a wider pool of applicants. I suggest that a more rigorous system of post-CCT tracking is needed to identify what happens to those anaesthetists who achieve CCT but apparently do not apply for substantive consultant appointments. The Royal College of Physicians conducts an annual census of its consultants and registrars, which delivers invaluable workforce information 35. The RCoA has conducted similar surveys in the past 36, most recently in 2010, and a 2015 survey has recently been announced 37. An annual survey could usefully be repeated to explore the career tracks of LTFT trainees after appointment into consultant roles, as well as those fellows who gain a CCT but are not currently recorded as being in a consultant post. As most anaesthetic departments now have experience of including part-time doctors in work schedules, this can only benefit the specialty in the future. More anaesthetists may need to work part-time if caring for elderly parents, and older anaesthetists may seek to reduce their hours when NHS retirement age increases. The demand for LTFT training has increased over the past decade, and this is likely to continue to grow. The value placed on work-life balance by Generation Y (those born after 1980) 38 means that more men are requesting LTFT, and this is increasingly accepted as a valid career/life choice. The current requirement for medical trainees to have a ‘well founded’ reason for LTFT is also likely to be challenged, as current legislation gives all workers the right to request flexible working 39 and there will be trainees who wish to access LTFT training as a lifestyle choice. Anaesthesia training programmes are well prepared and structured to support LTFT training, and this can be used to promote and recruit to the specialty. I am an independent career support coach and trainer, and a past consultant anaesthetist, Bernard Johnson Advisor for LTFT training at the RCoA, Associate Dean for Careers and LTFT in Wales, and Chair of the UK Medical Careers Group at the Department of Health. The views expressed in this editorial are my personal ones. No other competing interests or external funding declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Melanie Jones (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: