Key result
The Naughton protocol with a 1/8 updating factor yielded significantly lower noise and higher validation rates for microvolt T-wave alternans during treadmill stress testing compared to the Ellestad protocol.
Why the study?
Tools are sought to identify individuals susceptible to sudden cardiac death, prompting evaluation of the modified moving average methodology to obtain microvolt T-wave alternans using treadmill specific protocols.
Does the Naughton protocol compared to the Ellestad protocol improve the measurement of microvolt T-wave alternans using the modified moving average methodology during treadmill stress testing?
Observational (n=539)
No
Does the Naughton protocol compared to the Ellestad protocol improve the measurement of microvolt T-wave alternans using the modified moving average methodology during treadmill stress testing?
The Naughton protocol with a 1/8 updating factor is a viable method for the simultaneous performance of treadmill stress testing and measurement of microvolt T-wave alternans.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Naughton protocol may facilitate combined stress testing and MTWA; leaves open clinical utility versus Ellestad in prospective studies.
Sudden cardiac death is impactful. There has been an increase in the search for tools capable of identifying individuals who are most susceptible, such as the microvolt T-wave alternans. This study aims to analyze the applicability of the modified moving average methodology to obtain the microvolt T-wave alternans using treadmill specific protocols. Medical records of patients during the period August 2006-December 2014 were retrospectively analyzed. Five hundred and thirty nine exams were then included, divided into groups according to the protocol and updating factor used: Ellestad factor 8 or 32, Naughton factor 8 or 32. The topics for analysis were the alternans behavior, noise and validation according to the groups of leads analyzed (frontal, transversal and orthogonal planes).The greater microvolt T-wave alternans was found during the stress phase in most of the tests. Group Naughton 8 presented lower noise in this phase for the transverse and orthogonal planes (p=0.0082 and p<0.0001), with greater validation of frontal and orthogonal planes in comparison with group Ellestad 8 (p=0.0002 and 0.0008). The results indicate the viability of simultaneous performance of the stress test and measurement of the T wave alternans with Naughton protocol with 1/8 updating factor.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Filho et al. (2022) conducted an observational in Patients undergoing treadmill stress testing (n=539). Naughton protocol with 1/8 updating factor vs. Ellestad protocol with 1/8 updating factor was evaluated on Validation rate of frontal leads during maximum TWA moment (p=0.0002). The Naughton protocol with a 1/8 updating factor yielded significantly lower noise and higher validation rates for microvolt T-wave alternans during treadmill stress testing compared to the Ellestad protocol.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: