Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Table 1 shows the increase in risk associated with consumption of 1 g per day of alcohol. The estimates in these studies had been adjusted for major confounders, notably smoking. With respect to breast cancer, the estimate was derived from a meta-analysis of 53 studies, conducted by the Collaborative Group on Hormonal Factors in Breast Cancer ( Hamajima et al, 2002 ), which found that the risk was increased by 7.1% for every 10 g of daily alcoholintake. The values observed in subsequent studies are not substantially different. A pooled analysis of six cohort studies with data on alcohol and dietary factors found that the risk of breast cancer increased monotonically with increasing intake of alcohol; the multivariate relative risk (RR) for a 10-g per day increase in alcohol was 1.09 (95% CI=1.04–1.13; Smith-Warner et al, 1998 ). The EPIC study ( Tjønneland et al, 2007 ) found that the risk was 1.03 (95% CI=1.01–1.05) per 10-g per day recent alcohol intake, whereas in the Million Women Study the increase in risk associated with 10 g per day intake was 12% ( Allen et al, 2009 ). With respect to cancers of the colorectum, a pooled analysis of eight cohort studies reported a borderline statistically significant 16% risk increase for people drinking 30–45 g per day of alcohol and a significant 41% risk increase for people drinking ⩾ 45 g per day ( Cho et al, 2004 ). A more recent meta-analysis of cohort studies found a 15% increase in the risk of colon or rectal cancer for an increase of 100 g alcohol intake per week ( Moskal et al, 2007 ), with no difference between men and women. In the EPIC study ( Ferrari et al, 2007 ), the effect was a bit weaker, with alcohol intake at study baseline increasing colorectal cancer risk by 9% per 15 g per day, a risk greater for rectal cancer than for cancer of the distal colon, which in turn was greater than the risk for cancer of the proximal colon. In the WCRF (2007) report, a meta-analysis of eight studies of colon cancer yielded a combined RR of 1.09 (1.03–1.14) per 10 g intake per day, and a meta-analysis of nine studies of rectal cancer yielded an RR of 1.06 (1.01–1.12) per 10 g intake per day. The means in the meta-analyses of Cho et al (2004) , Moskal et al (2007) , the EPIC study ( Ferrari et al, 2007 ) and WCRF (2007) are 0.75% per gram alcohol per day for colon cancer and 0.85% per gram per day for rectal cancer. As these estimates are similar, the global figure of 0.8% per gram (increase of 0.008 per gram per day) was used for colorectal cancer as a whole ( Table 1 ). For the remaining cancers, the meta-analysis of Corrao et al (2004) was used to estimate the RRs. They present RRs associated with a mean intake of 0, 25, 50 and 100 g of alcohol per day. The RR per gram of alcohol intake was estimated by assuming a log–linear relationship between exposure and risk, so that: where x is the exposure level (in grams per day). The latent period or interval between ‘exposure’ to alcohol and the appropriate increase in risk of these cancers is not known. We chose to assume that this would be, on average, 10 years, and thus examine the effects on cancers occurring in 2010 from non-optimal levels of alcohol consumption in the year 2000. There are two main ways of measuring the amount of alcohol consumed: asking people how much alcohol they drink or counting how much alcohol is sold. As the estimates of the effect of past alcohol drinking on cancer risk are based on epidemiological studies in which alcohol intake is estimated from questionnaire data, it is most appropriate to base the exposure prevalence on data from a similar source. We have used data from the National Diet and Nutrition Survey, a survey of the diet and nutrition of a representative sample of adults in the age group of 19–64 years living in private households in Great Britain, carried out between July 2000 and June 2001 ( Henderson et al, 2003 ). For the age group >65 years, we used data on the proportion of non-drinkers, and average alcohol consumption from the General Household Survey (for England) ( Goddard, 2006 ). From these tables, an estimate was prepared of the proportions of individuals (by age group and sex) consuming different quantities of alcohol in terms of grams per day, assuming that 1 unit of alcoholic beverages contains 8 g of pure alcohol ( Table 2 ). The same data are shown in Figure 1 , as the cumulative percentages of men and women of different ages with different levels of alcohol intake in 2000, as grams per day of alcohol. Cumulative percentage of population with different alcohol intakes. For the six cancer types, PAFs were calculated for each sex–age group according to the usual formula: where p x is the proportion of the population in consumption level x ( x =1–12) and ERR x the excess relative risk (RR x −1) in consumption level x ( x =1–12). The ERR of alcohol consumption for each level x of alcohol consumption given in Table 2 was calculated as follows: where R g is the increase in risk per gram of alcohol intake ( Table 1 ) and G x the intake of alcohol (grams per day) in consumption category x ( Table 2 ). Table 3 shows for each sex and age group the numbers of cases of the six alcohol-related cancers in the UK in 2010, the PAFs due to alcohol consumption 10 years earlier (2000–2001) and the corresponding number of excess cases (calculated as (observed × PAF)). Because of the high risk of upper aero-digestive tract cancer associated with alcohol drinking, cancers of the mouth and pharynx, as well as larynx, had the highest percentages of alcohol-attributable cases (30.4% of cancers of the oral cavity and pharynx, 24.6% of laryngeal cancers). Although the fractions of colorectal (11.6%) and breast (6.4%) cancers were much lower, the actual numbers of alcohol-attributable cases were much greater – together, they account for about 7700 alcohol-attributable cases in 2010 (or 62% of all alcohol-related cancers). Table 4 sums the excess numbers of cases at the six sites, caused by alcohol consumption, and expresses these numbers as a fraction of the total burden of (incident) cancer. The estimates are 4.6% cancers in men and 3.3% in women due to alcohol consumption, or 4.0% cancers overall.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
D M Parkin (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: