Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We thank Drs Stockdale and Savic for their comments on our article ‘Peri-operative refractory anaphylactic shock during hepatic hydatid cyst surgery’ [1, 2], in which they note the unusually long duration of haemodynamic compromise and raise questions about our diagnosis of anaphylaxis. According to guidance from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases/Food Allergy and Anaphylaxis Network (NIAFD/FAAA) and the European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (EAACI), the diagnosis of anaphylaxis is essentially based on clinical criteria, including rapid onset of multiple symptoms and signs, for identifying anaphylaxis in an acute context [3]. Our patient had no history of allergy; induction general anaesthesia with propofol, fentanyl and atracurium was uneventful; and they remained haemodynamically stable until over 2 h into the surgery when rupture of the hydatid cyst occurred. It is well known that the spillage of highly antigenic Echinococcus fluid containing specific IgE immunoglobulin into the peritoneal cavity can cause anaphylaxis [4]. In an otherwise haemodynamically stable patient, the acute occurence of urticaria and severe haemodynamic instability a few minutes after spillage of hydatid fluid into peritoneal cavity led us to the conclusion that the causative agent was hydatid antigen [2]. In a prospective study, the clinical NIAID/FAAN criteria were found to be highly sensitive (95%) for the diagnosis of anaphylaxis in emergency settings [5]. Serial measurement of serum mast cell tryptase (MCT) is the gold standard for diagnosing anaphylaxis, but this test is unfortunately not available in our institution [2]. However, factors such as baseline values, causative agents and timing of blood sample may alter its importance [6]. In a study by Francis et al., measurement of peak and delta MCT concentrations were higher in anaphylaxis than other forms of critical illness [7], but the sensitivity and specificity was low and, hence, MCT values alone cannot be used to establish the diagnosis of anaphylaxis without clinical correlation. As such, the absence of MCT measurement cannot rule out anaphylaxis in our case report. Should this patient require further surgery due to recurrence of hydatid cyst, measurement of IgE immunoglobulins and skin testing may warn us of the risk of further anaphylaxis. In such cases, preoperative steroids may be indicated. Our patient had severe metabolic acidosis on the first postoperative day, requiring dialysis. This suggests severe hypoperfusion of organs. The patient continued to require three vasopressor agents to maintain blood pressure. Although they developed a moderate degree of pyrexia on the third postoperative day and antibiotics were given, this could have been due to an inflammatory response to surgery or critical illness, rather than infection. There were no overt signs suggestive of sepsis and C-reactive protein and calcitonin levels were within the normal ranges. Our patient had a long duration of refractory haemodynamic compromise following clinically diagnosed anaphylaxis. A recent multidisciplinary Delphi study found agreement that anaphylaxis can be prolonged, but noted that there are insufficient data to define time limits for anaphylaxis [8]. We did not find any article where the duration of anaphylaxis was more than few days and hence reported this unusual case with an onset characteristic of anaphylaxis and prolonged clinical features. No external funding and no conflicts of interest declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gundappa et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: