Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The study of decision-making practice in the context of media production has been dominated by social accounts focused on the interaction of the individual, group, institution, and wider society. Cognitive perspectives on such decision making have received relatively less attention. This article attempts to balance the existing focus on the social with an exploratory investigation of the efficacy of cognitive models of decision making developed in other fields to the study of media production.It argues that researchers should pay as much attention to the cognitive processes of decision makers as to the analysis of the character of overt decision-making behavior in groups, which has characterized much of the work on media production (particularly in ethnographic studies), if a full understanding of such decision making is to be developed. It suggests that perspectives developed in other fields may offer the prospect of greater insight into such cognitive processes.This article focuses on a specific decision-making context (i.e., producers and their teams working in the television sector on the selection of ideas to feed the product development process). It proposes the operation of at least 2 different modes of decision making, and uses naturalistic decision-making models as a way of exploring cognitive process in 1 of them. In doing so, it attempts to more precisely address the rather crudely defined concept of “gut instinct,” and speculates on how it might be operationalized and, hence, studied.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J. Roberts (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: