Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Instrumented indentation is a promising non-destructive method for assessing the fracture toughness of engineering structures. A foundational assumption in existing methods is that the elastic modulus obtained from spherical indentation decreases with depth, attributed to ductile damage induced by the indentation itself (called indentation-induced damage). However, this assumption lacks systematic experimental validation, and conflicting observations—reporting stable or even increasing modulus values—remain unexplained. Here, spherical indentation tests on four ductile metals (P92 steel, AA7075, AA2014, and TC4) show that the modulus does not exhibit a depth-dependent decrease. This study further investigates the mechanisms of elastic modulus degradation in P92 steel during plastic deformation and evaluates the sensitivity of instrumented indentation to different degradation mechanisms. The results reveal that during uniaxial tension, elastic modulus degradation prior to necking is primarily driven by reversible dislocation motion rather than void damage, whereas the indentation-derived elastic modulus is insensitive to dislocation effects but responds selectively to void-induced damage. Grid nanoindentation mapping on cross-sections of residual spherical indentations demonstrates that indentation-induced damage is spatially confined to a narrow region near the contact edge, where localized void nucleation is confirmed by electron microscopy. Crucially, the compressive stress state beneath the indenter fundamentally suppresses void growth and damage evolution. Finite element simulations incorporating experimentally-calibrated damage distributions confirm that the localized damage produces negligible variation in the measured elastic modulus. These findings challenge the core assumption underlying current indentation-based fracture toughness methods and provide mechanistic insights essential for developing reliable non-destructive evaluation techniques for ductile materials.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: