Key result
Noninvasive BP accurately tracks intraarterial pressure only for hypotensive mean and hypertensive systolic values.
Why the study?
Accurate blood pressure measurement during general anesthesia is critical, but it is unclear how well noninvasive oscillometric BP reflects direct intraarterial BP across different BP levels.
Does noninvasive oscillometric blood pressure measurement accurately reflect invasive arterial blood pressure during general anesthesia?
Observational (n=10)
No
Does noninvasive oscillometric blood pressure measurement accurately reflect invasive arterial blood pressure during general anesthesia?
This study evaluates the accuracy of noninvasive oscillometric blood pressure measurement compared to invasive arterial monitoring during general anesthesia.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Noninvasive BP accuracy varies by component and state during GA; hypothesis-generating and should not yet alter monitoring practice.
Background: Blood pressure (BP) varies considerably during general anesthesia.Accurate BP measurement is critical for appropriate treatment, especially during hypotension and hypertension.Here we evaluated whether the noninvasive oscillometric BP measurement technique accurately reflects BP measured by the direct intraarterial technique.Methods: A total of 256 samples were extracted from 10 patients operated on under general anesthesia.Systolic, diastolic and mean BP were analyzed according to the level of BP; hypotension, normotension, and hypertension.Repeatability of the noninvasive BP measurement were analyzed with repeatability coefficients and percent errors.Agreement between the two BP measurements were analyzed with a Bland-Altman and Modified Bland-Altman analysis.Results: The repeatability coefficient for mean BP of the noninvasive oscillometric BP measurement was 6.34.Percent errors of mean BP were smaller than those of systolic and diastolic BP.All biases were less than 5 mmHg at all BP levels.Most BP agreements were larger than 8 mmHg except all-range mean BP (7.7), hypotensive diastolic BP (6.7), and mean BP (6.2).During hypotension, only mean BP was within the 95% of confidence interval (CI) of bias and limit of agreement.During hypertension, only systolic BP could meet the criteria.Conclusions: Only mean BP during hypotension and systolic BP during hypertension accurately reflect the direct intraarterial BP.But, diastolic BP does not reflect the direct intraarterial BP over all BPs.(Korean J Anesthesiol 2008; 54: 493∼500)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Park et al. (2008) conducted an observational in Patients undergoing general anesthesia (n=10). Noninvasive oscillometric blood pressure measurement (Tram 800SL module) vs. Invasive arterial blood pressure measurement (AMK 250 AutoTransducer) was evaluated on Agreement between noninvasive and invasive blood pressure measurements evaluated by Bland-Altman analysis (Bias for mean BP -3.04 mmHg, systolic BP -0.16 mmHg, diastolic BP -3.84 mmHg). During general anesthesia, only noninvasive mean blood pressure during hypotension and systolic blood pressure during hypertension accurately reflected direct intraarterial measurements.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: