Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Himalayas and Alps, both shaped by Tethys Suture Zone evolution, manifest fundamentally different mechanical features throughout their geological development. Over the past century, the Alps have successfully completed numerous tunnel and underground engineering projects, with the New Austrian Tunneling Method (NATM) predominant due to numerous advantages. Deep-buried tunneling in the Himalayas differs markedly from that in the Alps, exhibiting higher geostress (> 80 MPa vs. 48 MPa), elevated ground temperatures (> 90 °C vs. 49 °C), more frequent fault zones (8–9 vs. 3–4), greater seismic intensity (magnitude 8.6 vs. 7), and larger tunnel deformations (> 3 m vs. 2.1 m), primarily due to the region’s exclusive geological and geomechanical conditions. The exceptionally high geostress, complex fault networks, and extensive rock deformation in the Himalayas render the self-supporting mechanism of NATM inadequate. This study systematically interrogates the geological and mechanical divergence between these mountain systems, emphasizing NATM's limitations in high geostress, soft rock environments. The Excavation Compensation Method (ECM), which strategically employs prestressing to counterbalance stress release induced by excavation, emerges as a recommended core technology for deep-buried Himalayan tunnelling. Case studies from the Muzhailing, Changning, and Tabaiyi tunnels validate ECM's efficacy through the implementation of high-strength prestressed cable anchors and NPR anchor technologies. • An extensive survey between the Himalayas and the Alps reveals significant geological and mechanical divergences. • The major shortcoming of NATM’s self-supporting mechanism is identified in the high-stress and soft-rock circumstances. • The ECM emerges as a superior alternative for Himalayan tunneling by employing prestressing to counterbalance excavation-induced stress release. • The ECM's effectiveness is validated through prestressed cable anchors and NPR anchor technologies in Muzhailing, Changning, and Tabaiyi tunnels.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
He et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: