Key result
Conventional roentgen examination combined with clinical findings is sufficient for selecting the great majority of congenital heart disease cases for surgery without complex procedures.
Why the study?
Can conventional roentgen examination adequately select patients with operable congenital heart disease for surgery compared to angiocardiography and heart catheterization?
Can conventional roentgen examination adequately select patients with operable congenital heart disease for surgery compared to angiocardiography and heart catheterization?
Conventional roentgen examination combined with clinical findings is sufficient for selecting most patients with congenital heart disease for surgery, reserving complex procedures for obscure cases.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Simplifies preoperative evaluation for most congenital heart disease; leaves open validation against contemporary imaging in current practice.
The recent remarkable developments in the field of vascular surgery offering cure or palliation to those afflicted with certain forms of congenital heart disease (13, 3, 6, 12, 16) have made diagnosis in this field a much more pressing practical problem for the roentgenologist than it has ever been in the past. Heart catheterization (18, 8) and angiocardiography (19) are increasingly stressed because of the accurate anatomical and physiological data they often provide in a field where the label “congenital heart” was formerly the common final clinical diagnosis. To be successful, these methods require special equipment and specially skilled personnel. They entail a certain amount of discomfort and inconvenience to the patient and add at least some element of hazard to the diagnostic work-up of a case. Since the roentgenologic pictures in the various forms of congenital heart disease very often do not fit the classic textbook descriptions, there is a tendency to believe that the more elaborate methods of examination are required routinely. It has seemed worthwhile to review briefly the roentgen findings in the congenital heart lesions which at present are amenable to surgical measures, since it is our belief that from a practical point of view the selection of cases for surgery can be made, in the great majority of cases, from a careful correlation of the findings by the ordinary roentgenologic and clinical methods. It has happened that to date no use has been made of angiocardiography or heart catheterization in the selection of cases for operation at the University of Minnesota Hospitals. Cases in which there was any serious doubt as to the diagnosis were not subjected to surgery, but the number of cases thus rejected is relatively small. It remains to be proved that the advantages of surgery will be made available to any considerable additional number of cases through the application of angiocardiography and heart catheterization. It may be that detailed angiocardiographic knowledge of the vascular arrangement in the individual case will eventually be demanded by the surgeon, but to date the great majority of cases that have been successfully operated upon in the various centers have been prepared for surgery without the more complex procedures. It is not intended to minimize in any sense the role of angiocardiography and catheterization, but rather to indicate that their prime clinical value is in the occasionally encountered obscure case. We desire to emphasize certain broad general features of the roentgen picture which, when correlated with the clinical findings, permit a practical diagnostic classification and prognosis as to the possibility of benefit from surgical intervention. Certain variations from the classical pictures occur frequently enough to be important and will be stressed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Herbert M. Stauffer (1949) conducted a review in Congenital heart disease. Conventional roentgen examination vs. Angiocardiography and heart catheterization was evaluated. Conventional roentgen examination combined with clinical findings is sufficient for selecting the great majority of congenital heart disease cases for surgery without complex procedures.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: