Key result
Endoscopic injection sclerotherapy for bleeding cardiac varices resulted in a significantly higher 1-month mortality rate compared to esophageal varices (66.7% vs 37.0%, p=0.0278).
Why the study?
Is endoscopic injection sclerotherapy with 1.5% Sotradecol effective and safe for bleeding cardiac varices compared to esophageal varices?
Case-Control (n=54)
Is endoscopic injection sclerotherapy with 1.5% Sotradecol effective and safe for bleeding cardiac varices compared to esophageal varices?
Absolute Event Rate: 66.7% vs 37%
p-value: p=0.0278
While endoscopic injection sclerotherapy with 1.5% Sotradecol controls immediate bleeding in cardiac varices similarly to esophageal varices, it is associated with higher 1-month mortality and complications.
Higher mortality after sclerotherapy for cardiac varices warrants caution; leaves open safer alternatives in this high-risk group.
The authors retrospectively studied the efficacy of endoscopic injection sclerotherapy (EIS) with 1.5% Sotradecol (STD) in patients with bleeding cardiac varices (CV). Case histories of 27 patients with large, isolated, bleeding CVs were reviewed. Case records of another 27 patients with isolated esophageal varices (EV), matched for age, sex, and year EIS was performed, were selected from a computer data bank as controls. Using a small volume (2-4 ml) of injection per vessel, the rate of immediate control of bleeding was 66.7% (18 of 27) in the CV group and 70.4% (19 of 27) in the EV group. The early rebleeding rate was higher for patients in the EV group (48.1%, 13 of 27) than for those in the CV group (18.5%, 5 of 27) (p = 0.0209). On the other hand, it was more difficult to control the rebleeding from CV (p = 0.00494). In terms of mortality, there was no statistically significant difference between the CV and EV groups (33.3 versus 29.6%) within 1 week after EIS, but the 1-month post-EIS mortality rate was significantly higher (p = 0.0278) in the CV group (18 of 27, 66.7%) than in the EV group (10 of 27, 37.0%). Among those in the CV group who died of late complications within 1 month after EIS, three died of recurrent hemorrhage, five of infection, and one of viscus perforation. In the EV group, only two patients died of infection. Thus, it was concluded that EIS with small volumes (2-4 ml) of 1.5% STD was equally effective in controlling immediate bleeding from CV and EV. However, it was more difficult to control early rebleeding from CV, and the mortality and complications within 1 month after EIS were significantly higher in patients with CV. These observations are currently under careful study and evaluation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chiu et al. (1997) conducted a case-control in Bleeding cardiac varices (n=54). Endoscopic injection sclerotherapy with 1.5% Sotradecol vs. Patients with isolated esophageal varices receiving the same treatment was evaluated on 1-month post-EIS mortality rate (p=0.0278). Endoscopic injection sclerotherapy for bleeding cardiac varices resulted in a significantly higher 1-month mortality rate compared to esophageal varices (66.7% vs 37.0%, p=0.0278).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: