Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Received wisdom commends a policy of maximizing the ratio of below-knee to above-knee amputations in patients with end-stage arterial disease. After adoption of this policy, the long-term outcome of 100 consecutive lower-limb amputations in 96 patients was monitored by annual review for 5 years. The ratio of primary below-knee to above-knee amputations was 2:1, with 9 per cent of below-knee amputations undergoing revision to a higher level. At 2 years after amputation only 26 per cent of patients were successfully walking out of doors, while 40 per cent had died. By 5 years 67 per cent were dead and only 9 per cent continued to walk out of doors with an artificial limb, although a further 8 per cent continued to use the limb within the confines of their own homes. In a previous audit of 193 amputations performed during the 3.5 years to December 1984, stump healing was a problem in 45 per cent of primary below-knee amputations, compared with 25 per cent in the present study. Although the below- to above-knee ratio in 1984 was only 1:2, the overall rehabilitation rate, as determined by the proportion of patients able to walk at 2 years, was 34 per cent. It is concluded that increasing the proportion of below-knee amputations from one-third to two-thirds of lower-limb amputations for occlusive arterial disease does not improve effective rehabilitation rates. Received wisdom on the desirability of a high below- to above-knee ratio may be wrong.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
McWhinnie et al. (1994) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: