This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Clinical science is imperfect. As any reader of this and other journals is aware, it is difficult to collect clean, prospective data over a long period of time on trauma patients. When the data is collected, it is often incomplete or flawed, because the scoring systems were incorrectly used or novel. This leads to several problems, not least the fact that the data cannot be compared between publications. This is the inherent flaw in meta-analyses, where authors start with very large numbers of patients, only to watch the meaningful data dwindle based on heterogeneous patient populations, fractures types, implants used, and finally multiple scoring systems. In an excellent article by Horwitz et al, the latter problem was evaluated in this issue of JOT. They noted that a total of 171 articles (34%) submitted between 2006 and 2010 used at least 1 functional outcome score. The average number of articles per year that reported functional outcome instruments was only 56% (range, 47%–65%), and the average number of articles that reported at least 1 validated outcome instrument was 51% (range, 44%–61%). Unfortunately, the average percentage of validated scores that were appropriately used within the category of interest was 23% (range, 13%–41%). While this is at least encouraging, it is equally sobering. We should, and can, do better. It is not enough for authors to use a functional outcome instrument; if it is not validated and site specific, it provides no useful data. For example, the ASES shoulder score is a site specific validated outcome score, and is ideal when reporting clinical outcomes for proximal humeral fractures. In an effort to accomplish this, the Journal would like studies analyzing patient function to use validated, site specific, functional outcome scores. This will be documented in the Instructions for Authors. It is the hope of the Editorial Board, that this will once again raise the bar for outcome data collection, in an effort to help our readers make educated decisions regarding patient care. A site specific, validated, functional outcome score is only in this way that we can compare data in a meaningful way.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Roy Sanders (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: