Key result
Maximal treadmill exercise ST segment responses were comparable between healthy men and women, suggesting the lower predictive value of exercise ECG in women relates to disease prevalence.
Why the study?
Does maximal treadmill exercise elicit different ST segment responses in healthy females compared to healthy males?
Cohort (n=232)
Does maximal treadmill exercise elicit different ST segment responses in healthy females compared to healthy males?
Exercise ST segment responses are comparable between healthy males and females, suggesting that the lower predictive value of exercise ECG in women is likely related to a different baseline prevalence of coronary artery disease rather than a different physiological response.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports comparable exercise ECG interpretation in men and women; leaves open whether prevalence adjustment enhances diagnostic accuracy in women.
In order to evaluate both quantitatively and qualitatively exercise ST response in females, we have studied 232 healthy subjects (age range 35-59 years): 82 women (mean age 45.8 years) and 150 men (mean age 46.1 years). All subjects had performed a maximal treadmill exercise in 1976 and were followed up for 6 years in order to exclude the presence of subclinical coronary artery disease. Exercise ST segment responses were evaluated in a single bipolar lead (CB5) and were classified as 'positive' by visual interpretation when a 1.0-mm or greater 'ischemic' ST depression occurred. A computer system was employed to evaluate exercise ST changes quantitatively. The following ST parameters were evaluated: ST depression at R + 80 ms point (ST2); mean ST depression (STmean), and ST time-voltage integral (STarea). Computer analysis of resting ECG has shown lower ST voltages in females than in males. ST2, STarea, and STmean changes from basal to maximal exercise values were not significantly different in men and women. A similar prevalence of 'positive' responses in males and females was also found by ECG visual interpretation. In conclusion, our data show that in healthy subjects exercise ST segment response is comparable in males and females and indirectly suggest that the lower predictive value of exercise ECG in women is likely to be related to different coronary artery disease prevalence.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Manca et al. (2008) conducted a cohort in Healthy (n=232). Female sex vs. Male sex was evaluated on Exercise ST segment changes (ST2, STmean, STarea) and prevalence of positive responses. Maximal treadmill exercise ST segment responses were comparable between healthy men and women, suggesting the lower predictive value of exercise ECG in women relates to disease prevalence.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: