Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial challenges the proposed restructuring of pediatric anesthesia services, arguing that concentrating care to a single designated anesthetist would leave emergency cases to less experienced on-call staff.
The first editorial of the June issue (Anaesthesia 1997; 51: 513-5) puts forward, not for the first time, the case for drastic restructuring of paediatric surgical and anaesthesia services, which would effectively concentrate all the paediatrics into the care of one anaesthetist. This would have very serious consequences. On the plus side, that Designated Paediatric Anaesthetist (DPA) will have greater recent experience. This would not be up to Lunn's recommended levels [1], but nor is most paediatric anaesthesia. There is unlikely to be much effect on standards, as NCEPOD 89 found these were excellent overall in DGHs [2]. But what of the effect on the other anaesthetists? The DPA clearly cannot [3] be available for all paediatric anaesthetic emergencies. The on-call consultant will have to cope. This will sometimes be the DPA, more often one of the others, who will have no recent experience in the field. Thus the sickest children, the emergencies, will be looked after by the least experienced. This conclusion cannot be supported: how do the recommendations which lead us to it arise? The only source is NCEPOD 1989 [2]. This large survey condemned occasional paediatric anaesthetists and recommended the changes outlined above. Perhaps surprisingly, however, it contains no data to support the recommendations. Though there were, not surprisingly, a few concerning cases, standards of anaesthesia were generally excellent. The first editorial purports to quote NCEPOD 89 [2], stating that standards of anaesthesia were only ‘satisfactory’, and continues ‘… it was clear that when “avoidable deaths” were considered some improvements could be made in the organisation of surgical services ...’ This statement surprised us. We have reviewed NCEPOD 89 in search of its source and could find nothing. There was no reference to anaesthetic ‘avoidable deaths’. The only critical data were the five worrying cases discussed (pp. 149-151 of the report), of which probably only one would be handled differently if the proposed changes were implemented (two would still be handled, as DGH emergencies, by the non-DPA anaesthetist). These cases do not support the NCEPOD 89 recommendations [2]. The other major reference is to Atwell & Spargo [4], an unsystematic review, whose only UK anaesthesia source is NCEPOD 89 [2]. This includes the remark ‘There are no data comparing paediatric anaesthetic morbidity in the DGH with that in the regional paediatric unit.‘ The first editorial refers to quoted [4] increased mortality in pyloric stenosis and intussusception outside centralised paediatric units, but these in fact are surgical deaths, not anaesthetic. The other references, including Lunn's recommendations [1], are all based on NCEPOD's and contain no data, nor re-analysis of data. Thus the only data are NCEPOD's, which showed that overall standards are excellent. There are no other data. If other data were forthcoming, they would be available by now. We are thus, in DGHs, being pushed into restructuring all our paediatric workload solely on the basis of an interpretation of NCEPOD which, frankly, it does not support. The second editorial purports to respond to the first, from the viewpoint of the DGH consultant (Anaesthesia 1997; 51: 515-6). This individual view does recognise that implementation of the NCEPOD 89 recommendations would result in the sickest patients being looked after by the least experienced (its 5th para), but astonishingly continues to support them! It says much for anaesthetists' common sense that this implementation has so far been resisted: such resistance should continue.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
HENEGHAN et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: