Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death (NCEPOD) has historically played a significant role in shaping clinical governance and improving patient safety in the UK, though its future funding and engagement with new clinicians remain challenging.
“And now, imagine the triumphant procession: Peter at the head; after him the hunters leading the wolf; and winding up the procession, grandfather and the cat. Grandfather shook his head discontentedly: ‘Well, and if Peter hadn’t caught the wolf? What then?’ ” –Sergei Prokofiev 1936 Traditionally, when considering the value and impact of clinical quantitative research, one should ask the question – so what? What difference has this study made to clinical practice and healthcare, and what has been the benefit to patients? [1]. The same is equally true for qualitative investigation. The National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death (NCEPOD) reviews clinical practice in all hospitals and should be judged by the same criteria for its impact on patient care. Hence, when assessing its impact, one should ask the question: ‘would healthcare in the UK be none the worse if NCEPOD did not exist?’. This question is particularly pertinent because the Government is currently undertaking a major reorganisation of the Department of Health’s ‘arm’s length bodies’, with drastic cuts in funding, and consequently the very existence of NCEPOD is uncertain [2]. In the late 1940s, the Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland (AAGBI) developed the idea that it might be possible to assess the factors that influence death associated with anaesthesia on a national basis [3]. This work was further developed in the 1970s by Dr John Lunn and Professor William Mushin, and culminated in the publication of the report ‘Mortality Associated with Anaesthesia’ in 1982 [4]. This was the first national study that undertook anonymous and confidential methods to collect and analyse information on peri-operative deaths. Following on from this report, John Lunn teamed up with the surgeon Brendan Devlin and with the support of the AAGBI and the Association of Surgeons of Great Britain and Ireland, and sponsored by the King’s Fund and Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust, they undertook a study to review 30-day peri-operative deaths in three regions in England. The report ‘A Confidential Enquiry into Perioperative Deaths’ was published in 1987 [5]. Recognising that peri-operative deaths were a major public health issue, the National Confidential Enquiry into Perioperative Deaths was established in 1988 to examine the quality of the delivery of care for surgical and anaesthetic patients [6]. At this time, the concepts of clinical audit or clinical governance were in their infancy. Consequently, there was considerable opposition from much of the medical profession to participate in such work, but, following the adage that ‘surgery, like cricket, is only interesting if you keep the score’, it was eventually accepted. The early work of NCEPOD centred on recommendations to improve hospital clinical information systems, the development of multidisciplinary team working with closer supervision of trainees, and the use of multidisciplinary clinical audit [7]. Thus, NCEPOD pioneered many of the components of clinical governance that led to the current culture of patient safety [8–12]. One of the strengths of NCEPOD from its inception has been that it is an independent organisation despite the fact that a majority of its funding comes from the Department of Health. This independence is maintained because NCEPOD is run and overseen by the healthcare profession. Representatives from relevant medical royal colleges, specialist associations and patient groups sit on the NCEPOD Steering Group, and as a charitable organisation it has a board of trustees. Historically, the aim of NCEPOD was to undertake independent reviews of clinical practice and identify remediable factors in the practice of anaesthesia and surgery. The remit was extended in 2002 to include medical patients and near misses. At this time, its name was changed to the ‘National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death’. However, the method has remained unchanged. The processes of healthcare assessed by NCEPOD are not amenable to statistical analysis, and the method is unashamedly based on qualitative peer review to investigate the multitude of processes involved in healthcare. It is the results of this peer review by senior clinicians, and not specific causation of death, that lead to the findings and recommendations of the published reports. Another of NCEPOD’s strengths is that clinical input on a day-to-day basis is provided by Clinical Coordinators who are practising consultants, seconded from NHS hospital trusts. In addition, it is the goodwill and cooperation of hospital consultants, completing questionnaires and acting as advisors, that allow NCEPOD to function so professionally and economically. A network of trust NCEPOD Local Reporters and Ambassadors, many of whom are clinicians, ensures that data are provided to NCEPOD from their trusts, ensuring that the local obligation to participate is met [13–15]. To date, NCEPOD has published in excess of 28 reports looking at various aspects of hospital healthcare. These have included numerous surgical studies and covered new ground such as the care of patients admitted to hospital as emergencies, medical admissions to intensive care units and the care of seriously injured patients. Furthermore, NCEPOD has reviewed specific disease processes and specialist hospital services such as acute kidney injury, sickle cell disease and thalassaemia, therapeutic endoscopy, systemic anticancer therapy and parenteral nutrition, to name a few. So the question is: have these reports influenced hospital clinical practice? The National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death has highlighted concerns about surgery performed out of hours by junior staff with too little supervision and emphasised the need for all the necessary resources and appropriately trained personnel to be available in order for surgery to take place, whatever the time [16]. The recommendation that has reduced the amount of out-of-hours operating and has been mostly widely accepted is that ‘the availability of staffed emergency operating theatres on a 24-h basis is essential’ [17]. In many hospitals, this change has been achieved by the introduction of ‘NCEPOD lists’ in dedicated emergency theatres. In the 2003 NCEPOD report, 60% of hospitals had NCEPOD operating theatres, and more recently this number is believed to have increased [18]. Whether these changes in hospital practice have reduced peri-operative morbidity and mortality is hard to determine, but the fact that NCEPOD's recommendations on emergency operating have been so widely adopted in the UK does indicate that from a process of care aspect, it would be hard to argue against there being a benefit to the quality of patient care. Perhaps the report that has caused most controversy over the last 23 years was in fact the first NCEPOD report, which reviewed surgery and anaesthesia in children [6]. On the face of it, the two main recommendations that have resulted in so much debate seem to be self-evident and common sense. These recommendations were that ‘surgeons and anaesthetists should not undertake occasional paediatric practice’ and ‘consultants who take the responsibility for the care of children (particularly in district general hospitals and in single surgical speciality hospitals) must keep up-to-date and competent in the management of children’. Of course, the question that has occupied the minds of both surgeons and anaesthetists is what is ‘occasional practice’, or rather, what constitutes acceptable practice to maintain competence? Initial attempts at defining this by numbers alone resulted in a loss of confidence by anaesthetists and surgeons in district general hospitals to care for children [19, 20]. This resulted in a decade of unwinding of children’s surgical services from these hospitals [21]. Even the NCEPOD report, ‘Extremes of Age’, published in 1999, which advocated the concept of clinical networks, failed to stem the flow of children’s surgery from peripheral to tertiary centres [22, 23]. Although in principle, greater centralisation of children’s surgery may encourage greater paediatric specialisation and concentration of expertise, there is a perception amongst clinicians from anecdotal evidence that this has been to the detriment of children’s surgical services in district general hospitals [24]. There is a concern regarding the deskilling of surgeons and anaesthetists who care for children in district general hospitals, limiting their ability to manage critically ill children who present at their hospital [25]. Although the responsibility for these changes does not wholly lie at NCEPOD’s door, it certainly had a role in their initiation. Currently, NCEPOD is revisiting children’s surgery in a study still in progress; let’s hope that it’s third time lucky! More recently, NCEPOD’s attention has been drawn to medical care, and NCEPOD has recommended that ‘each hospital should have a track and trigger system that allows rapid detection of the signs of early clinical deterioration and an early and appropriate response’ [26]. The National Patient Safety Agency (NPSA) and National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) have produced guidelines based on NCEPOD’s recommendations on systems to monitor and review acutely ill inpatients [27, 28]. Hospitals in the UK have been implementing these guidelines over the last few years. It is thought that many have been struggling to develop methods to ensure that appropriate systems are in place to escalate care to competent personnel before acute deterioration occurs (personal communication). Further examples where NCEPOD has influenced the delivery of healthcare include the development of NICE guidance on both sickle cell crisis [29] and acute kidney injury [30], and the National Chemotherapy Advisory Group’s new framework for commissioning, delivering and monitoring acute oncology services based on recommendations made by NCEPOD [31]. The Royal College of Physicians has adopted the NCEPOD recommendation that ‘patients admitted as an emergency should be seen by a consultant at the earliest opportunity. Ideally this should be within 12 h and should not be longer than 24 h [32]. Moreover, following the NCEPOD report on the seriously injured patient, a national clinical director for trauma care was appointed at the Department of Health [33]. One of the frequent criticisms of NCEPOD is that it fails to complete the audit loop to follow up on its recommendations, or to re-investigate previous report findings. Unfortunately, NCEPOD does not have resources to revisit every study it has undertaken although, as described above, there have been exceptions. Over the last 5 years, NCEPOD has forged good links with many healthcare organisations including the Department of Health, NPSA, NICE, the General Medical Council, the NHS Litigation Authority and the Care Quality Commission, to take its recommendations and compliance with them forward. The dissemination of NCEPOD’s recommendations is aimed at capturing the widest possible audience, including the medical royal colleges and specialist associations. Each report is launched with active engagement with the media, and key healthcare professionals receive copies of the reports. A self-assessment checklist is provided that can be used by hospitals to assess whether they comply with the recommendations, and for more recent reports, an audit toolkit will allow hospitals to replicate aspects of the study to close their own audit loop. The National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death is acutely aware that it has a reputation for persuading individuals and organisations to change how they deliver healthcare. It is viewed as a trusted organisation, independent from government influence that frequently ‘punches above its weight’. However, as its remit expands, it has a major challenge to engage with new clinicians who are unfamiliar with its previous work, particularly the younger generation of healthcare professionals (Opinion Leader Research, NCEPOD: a reputation audit, 2006: unpublished). So what does the future hold? There are several challenges ahead for NCEPOD, not least due to the presence of a new government and extreme budgetary pressures. It is likely that all the Confidential Enquires will face uncertain times over the next couple of years and their remit and composition may radically change. In the mean time, NCEPOD is undertaking a series of new studies including children’s surgery; peri-operative care in high-risk patients undergoing surgery and anaesthesia; in-hospital cardiac arrest procedures; and bariatric surgery. In addition, two reports, one reviewing surgery in the elderly and one reviewing the organisation of cosmetic surgery practice, are to be published in 2010. What lessons have been learnt by the studies that have been undertaken by NCEPOD in the last 23 years? Perhaps nothing too surprising for most of us. The quality of hospital healthcare is influenced by a complex combination of diverse factors and processes. These include the patient, healthcare personnel, the physical infrastructure, the management environment, training, and custom and traditional practice, to name a few. What makes a difference to the delivery of high quality healthcare? From reviewing the 28 NCEPOD reports, I would suggest there are three overriding themes: team working; communication; and attention to detail. So to return to the original question: would healthcare in the UK be none the worse if NCEPOD did not exist? “Well, you might very well think that; I couldn't possibly comment” [34]. The author is a Clinical Coordinator for NCEPOD and an author of several of the NCEPOD reports cited. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2044.2010.06533.x
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
D. G. Mason (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: