Key result
The National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death (NCEPOD) has utilized qualitative peer review over 30 years to identify remediable factors and improve healthcare quality in the UK.
Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Review
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
NCEPOD has significantly contributed to improving peri-operative and general patient care in the UK over the past 30 years through its confidential enquiry and peer review methodology.
‘Age cannot wither her nor custom stale her infinite variety’Antony and Cleopatra William Shakespeare (1606) The minutes of the first National Confidential Enquiry into Peri-operative Death (NCEPOD) Steering Group meeting on 15 December 1987 at 9 Bedford Square [first home of the Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland (AAGBI)] record that there was representation from the Association of Surgeons of Great Britain and Ireland (ASGBI), Royal College Of Surgeons (RCS) of England, Faculty of Anaesthetists of the RCS and the Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynaecology (RCOG). In attendance were Mr. Nigel Buck, Mr. Brendan Devlin and Dr. John Lunn – the co-authors of the first CEPOD report 1. Mr. Devlin and Dr. Lunn, together with Professor J.S Lumley, were the first clinicians to be appointed as NCEPOD Clinical Coordinators. From its inception, NCEPOD was an independent body made up of a cross-section of medical professionals whose aim was to examine the quality of care delivered to and received by patients who died in hospital within 30 days of a surgical procedure. The focus was to improve the quality of all aspects of patient care. This was to be achieved by identifying remediable factors in the process of care. It was recognised that these factors would relate to all patients undergoing surgery and not just those who died. Following the first report, an annual report was published, each with a different surgical focus; for example, surgery in the elderly and the young, or a specific procedure such as aortic aneurysms. In 1999, following the publication of ‘A First Class Service: Quality in the New NHS’ 2, the major funding body for NCEPOD (in England and Wales) was transferred from the Department of Health to the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). In 2002, NCEPOD extended its remit to review the care received by medical patients. Outcome measures were also extended to include serious incidents as well as death. To reflect this expanded remit there was a change of name in 2003 to the ‘National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death’. In 2011, overall responsibility for commissioning and funding was transferred to the Healthcare Quality Improvement Partnership (HQIP), an independent organisation led by the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges and established in 2008 to promote quality in healthcare, and to increase the impact of clinical audit and outcome programmes on healthcare quality improvement. Each health outcome review programme is overseen by an Independent (clinical) Advisory Group and the work of NCEPOD currently sits under both the Medicine/Surgery and the Child Health Independent Advisory Groups. Since 2016, all NCEPOD studies have included Scotland as well as all other parts of the UK. In 2018, NCEPOD will publish reports across the spectrum of medicine, surgery and child health and include mental as well as physical health, a broad view of primary and community-based care together with secondary care. Although NCEPOD was not the first organisation to use a peer review/confidential enquiry method, it was the first to do so in the peri-operative period. Qualitative and rigorous peer review continues as the mainstay of the NCEPOD method, but it is by no means the only approach used. As part of the annual topic selection process, NCEPOD, alongside the relevant Independent Advisory Group, undertakes an in-depth consideration of all submitted topics. Topics may be submitted by any individual and most are centred around a perceived problem area within healthcare. Not all lend themselves to examination within an NCEPOD study methodology. Following shortlisting and selection, topics are further developed within a protocol by a study advisory group made up of multidisciplinary experts in the area of care being examined. In most NCEPOD studies, clinical and organisational questionnaires are developed and clinical records are reviewed, alongside the completed questionnaires, by a panel of case reviewers. Reviewers receive training and attend round-table meetings where cases are examined in detail. The reviewers then form a judgment, often following multidisciplinary discussion, on the quality of various aspects of the care delivered. These reviewer meetings are moderated by a clinical coordinator – consultants selected from a range of disciplines who are seconded from their Trusts to work with NCEPOD in the same roles Devlin, Lumley and Lunn undertook in 1987. As well as a clinical review, NCEPOD studies also aim to provide a picture of the organisation of an individual service by asking leads of service, most commonly Medical Directors, to provide detail about infrastructure, standards and processes of care. To undertake the work, NCEPOD harnesses enormous volunteer resources from a network of local reporters (one in every hospital) who collate and collect data. This is supplemented by a growing group of Ambassadors – senior clinicians who support the work of NCEPOD and help disseminate and promote the findings and recommendations of NCEPOD reports. Members of the AAGBI are warmly thanked for their input in supporting or personally fulfilling these roles. Reports are launched into the public domain in many formats, all of which are freely available at www.ncepod.org.uk. Material includes a selection of short films 3, informatics and sound bites disseminated through social media (Facebook and Twitter). The NCEPOD is sometimes asked about how information of this nature can be safely collated and shared. Protecting the confidentiality of patients, relatives, staff and hospitals is paramount and means that NCEPOD can command trust from all these groups and provide assurance that detailed information security policies, which have been audited to ISO 27001 standards, are followed. NCEPOD is registered for the Data Protection Act and has HRA-CAG approval under Section 251 of the NHS Act 2006. This allows the organisation to collect these data without obtaining additional consent. Medical records have patient identity removed before review and any case scenarios presented in reports are scrutinised and if necessary further altered to ensure anonymity. NCEPOD has been able to demonstrate change linked to its recommendations. In the early years, undertaking an annual review of surgical mortality allowed changes in care to be identified. As clinicians, we have seen the arrival of ‘CEPOD’ emergency theatres and a reduction in out-hours operating, both advances attributed to NCEPOD's reports. We also know, historically, that it often took 5–10 years for recommendations to take effect. Despite NCEPOD's diversification from peri-operative deaths, its reports remain relevant to anaesthetists, intensivists and pain specialists. Inspiring Change (acute non-invasive ventilation), Treat the Cause (acute pancreatitis), Just Say Sepsis, Time to get Control (gastro-intestinal haemorrhage), Working Together (lower limb amputation) and On the Right Trach (tracheostomy care) all have findings of relevance to members of the AAGBI. Knowing the Risk (peri-operative care) has resulted in the development of the Surgical Outcome Risk Tool (SORT) available as an App 4. This report and An Age Old Problem (surgery in the elderly) are widely attributed in providing the basis for the ongoing National Emergency Laparotomy Audit (NELA). On reflection, we believe that NCEPOD's three most significant contributions to patient care delivered by anaesthetists are the universal availability of dedicated emergency operating time within normal working hours (CEPOD theatres); the increase in supervision of trainees out of hours; and the recognition of the need to adopt a multidisciplinary approach to patient care. NCEPOD's recommendations will not continue to improve the quality of care for patients unless organisations and professionals use them to implement change, assisting with local, regional and national quality improvement projects. Although dissemination of recommendations is key to the success of a study, they often also need to be followed up by real and credible contemporary data to become useful. Experience has also shown that recommendations must be relevant and timely 5. NCEPOD has forged good links with many other national healthcare organisations involved in quality improvement and is often able to reinforce or illuminate recommendations made by others and move them forward 6. As a result, NCEPOD often ‘punches above its own weight’ to influence clinical practice, and assist in the inception of new guidelines and processes. Over the years, a number of common themes have continued to emerge from NCEPOD that are key to the care of all patients admitted to hospital: consultant supervision and timely review; documentation and attention to good practice around consent; recognition of serious illness and appropriate escalation of care; and regular consideration of practice in the form of morbidity and mortality meetings and case reviews. Boulton, in his history of the AAGBI 7, cites many of these same themes when discussing Lunn and Mushin's early report on mortality associated with anaesthesia published in 1982 8. A more recent analysis of anonymous case records at the Medical Protection Society in which death was associated with anaesthesia also found, in common with these reports, that the principle contributory factors were inadequate supervision, pre-operative assessment and a failure of communication both within and between specialties 9. Undoubtedly, NCEPOD has elevated the role of peer review and reflection in everyday patient care, and it is also our opinion that the NCEPOD process has strengthened the team approach to the delivery of healthcare. Much of NCEPOD's strength is that it is clinically led and largely independent of governmental control, NHS management and professional institutions. These same groups are essential to make its work effective. The NCEPOD is a co-operative effort striving to narrow the gap between what should happen and what happens for patients in the NHS and private sectors. NCEPOD has undergone several formal reviews, both externally and internally led, to ensure that the organisation is fulfilling its requirements to the professions and the public. These have provided both a stimulus to debate within the Enquiry and helped to ensure that the Enquiry has retained its value in changing times. The quality of its work, the respect in which it is held and the impact it has had on the improvement of the NHS has been repeatedly acknowledged by the government, the professions and the public. Moving forward, what might NCEPOD do better? The qualitative nature of NCEPOD reviews can be misunderstood, and perhaps a greater emphasis on the benefits of qualitative review and the difference with quantitative research methodology need to be highlighted in order that the ‘NCEPOD method’ is better valued. On a more practical note, and to improve the job of clinicians filling in questionnaires, electronic data collection has commenced. As already mentioned, NCEPOD is now very well established on digital platforms to transmit its messages to an even wider audience including patients, and this will continue to develop further. In 2010, Mason highlighted the pressure new governments and their accompanying budgetary issues bring, and very little has changed in this respect in 2018 10. NCEPOD is optimistic that its pedigree, coupled with strong and consistent leadership and the excellent support that it receives from clinicians, will continue to allow it to flourish. We are confident that the future will present further challenges and opportunities to expand and tell more NCEPOD ‘stories’ and in doing so, improve care for all our patients. Both AG and KW are Clinical Co-ordinators for NCEPOD. No other competing interests.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Goodwin et al. (2018) reported a review. The National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcome and Death (NCEPOD) has utilized qualitative peer review over 30 years to identify remediable factors and improve healthcare quality in the UK.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: