Key result
Stentless bioprostheses displayed superior haemodynamics compared to stented or mechanical prostheses at 1 year postoperatively, though without differences in left ventricular mass reduction.
Why the study?
Do stentless bioprostheses improve haemodynamic performance compared to stented or mechanical prostheses in patients undergoing aortic valve replacement?
Cohort (n=106)
Do stentless bioprostheses improve haemodynamic performance compared to stented or mechanical prostheses in patients undergoing aortic valve replacement?
Stentless bioprostheses offer superior haemodynamic performance resembling normal native valves compared to stented or mechanical prostheses, though without a difference in left ventricular mass regression at 1 year.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Stentless valves' haemodynamic edge should not alter AVR practice; leaves open randomized confirmation of clinical benefit beyond 1 year.
BACKGROUND: In patients being considered for aortic valve replacement, there remains controversy over which design or tissue offers the best performance. We aimed to evaluate in a single study the haemodynamic performances of five different widely used aortic valve prostheses: stentless porcine xenograft (Elan), stentless bovine pericardium (Pericarbon Freedom), stented porcine xenograft (Aspire), stented bovine pericardium (More) and mechanical (Ultracor). We also compared them with normal aortic valves and stenosed valves of variable severity. METHODS AND RESULTS: Preoperative echocardiography and dobutamine stress echocardiography at 1 year postoperatively were undertaken in 106 patients (n=18-24 from each group). Stentless bioprostheses, whether porcine or bovine, displayed superior haemodynamics across nearly all echocardiographic parameters: lower gradients, larger effective orifice area, higher dimensionless severity index (DSI) and lower resistance, when compared with stented or mechanical prostheses. Comparing both stented designs, bovine tissue performed the worst at rest, but with stress, there was no difference. The stress performances of the stentless bioprostheses were similar to the mildly stenosed native aortic valve, whereas the performances of the stented and mechanical prostheses resembled that of native valves with mild-to-moderate stenoses. Haemodynamic differences, however, did not translate into differences in left ventricular mass reduction at 1 year. CONCLUSIONS: Stentless bioprostheses displayed haemodynamics superior to stented or mechanical prostheses and had the closest performance to a normal, native aortic valve. Stress DSI data, least reliant on variable annulus/valve sizes and flow rates, provided the best haemodynamic discrimination.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Khoo et al. (2012) conducted a cohort in Aortic valve replacement (n=106). Stentless bioprostheses vs. Stented or mechanical prostheses was evaluated on Haemodynamic performance (gradients, effective orifice area, dimensionless severity index, resistance). Stentless bioprostheses displayed superior haemodynamics compared to stented or mechanical prostheses at 1 year postoperatively, though without differences in left ventricular mass reduction.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: