Key result
Outer-to-inner (OTI) wall diameter measurements were the most repeatable and resilient to image processing, with 90% of deviations between -0.50 mm and +0.75 mm compared to the original image.
Why the study?
Does image processing affect the intra-observer reliability of abdominal aortic ultrasound diameter measurements, and which measurement method is most resilient?
Observational (n=3)
Single-blind
No
Does image processing affect the intra-observer reliability of abdominal aortic ultrasound diameter measurements, and which measurement method is most resilient?
Outer-to-inner (OTI) wall diameter measurements are the most reliable and resilient to image processing for abdominal aortic ultrasound, challenging current NHS screening guidelines.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
OTI measurements may improve aortic ultrasound repeatability; leaves open whether guidelines should prioritize them over current standards.
The aim of this feasibility study was to assess the impact that image processing of abdominal aortic ultrasound (US) images had on the intra-observer reliability of the diameter measurement. The study compared variability between inner-to-inner (ITI), outer-to-outer (OTO) and outer-to-inner (OTI) wall diameter measurements and their resilience to image processing. Three US images of transverse abdominal aortas were manipulated in 13 different ways using functions from Image J software (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA). Blinded measurements were performed of the aortic diameters from each image; this was repeated for ITI, OTO and OTI. Profiles of each image were produced and sets of rules developed to provide detailed instructions as to where, on the profile, the callipers should be placed to correspond with the actual image. The reliability of the diameter measurements compared to the original diameter measurement was least affected by adjusting the brightness and contrast of the US images (better than ± 1.5 mm). Using the functions 'Sharpen' and 'Find Edges' created the largest difference (up to -5 mm). The ITI measurements had the widest spread of variability, whereas the OTI measurements proved to be the most repeatable and resilient to image processing. This study suggests the precision of the measurements can be kept within satisfactory levels even after image manipulation. It also showed the most reliable measuring guideline was OTI, in contrast to the guideline currently used by the NHS Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Screening Programme. Further research is needed to transfer the findings into the clinical setting of the National Screening Programme to increase its reliability.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Smith et al. (2013) conducted an observational in Abdominal aortic aneurysm (n=3). Image processing manipulation and measurement guidelines (ITI, OTO, OTI) vs. Original unmanipulated images was evaluated on Intra-observer reliability of the diameter measurement (deviation from original image measurement). Outer-to-inner (OTI) wall diameter measurements were the most repeatable and resilient to image processing, with 90% of deviations between -0.50 mm and +0.75 mm compared to the original image.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: