Key result
Mitral ring dehiscence rates were higher among patients with rigid rings compared to semi-rigid and flexible rings.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Annuloplasty ring dehiscence is a rare but important complication of mitral and tricuspid valve repair, occurring more frequently with rigid rings and in patients with ischaemic mitral regurgitation.
The goals of mitral valve (MV) and tricuspid valve (TV) repair are to restore leaflet motion, to increase leaflet coaptation and to stabilize the annulus with preservation of an adequate valve orifice. Ring annuloplasty is mainly used to stabilize the annulus and to prevent subsequent annular dilatation as well as to restore annular geometry in the dilated annulus. In combination with several different repair techniques, ring annuloplasty allows a successful valve repair in most patients with degenerative disease. Mitral and tricuspid annuloplasty ring dehiscence is a rare postoperative procedure-related failure of MV or TV repair. Ring dehiscence is associated with recurrent mitral regurgitation (MR), haemolysis, device embolization or device migration and it is usually treated with an urgent or emergent reoperation [1]. In this issue of the EJCTS, Arjomandi Rad et al. [2] report a pooled analysis of previously published observational studies, investigating the incidence and predisposing factors for annuloplasty ring dehiscence. The reported overall ring dehiscence rate was 1.4% (ranged from 1% to 10%). Mitral ring dehiscence rates were significantly higher among patients with rigid rings (rigid 2.32%, semi-rigid 1.86%, flexible 0.43%; P < 0.001). Moreover, dehiscence rates were more frequently observed in patients with ischaemic MR in comparison to non-ischaemic MR (3.91% vs 1.63%; P = 0.022). Finally, ring size and shape did not have any influence on the dehiscence rates. Tricuspid ring dehiscence was reported in only one out of the 9 included studies. The authors conclude that ring characteristics, valve pathology, patient characteristics and technical factors are the primary risk factors for the occurrence of ring dehiscence after MV or TV repair. Considering the lack of evidence in annuloplasty ring dehiscence, Arjomandi Rad et al. have to be congratulated for their analysis because it is a comprehensive investigation to provide a more solid database, which can contribute to the improvement of MV or TV repair. The actual importance of annuloplasty ring dehiscence is not negligible and probably more patients than reported might be affected. Interestingly, the average occurrence of dehiscence in this cohort was early (4.5 months postoperatively). Hence, a more frequent echocardiographic follow-up during the first postoperative year, especially in patients with increased risk of ring dehiscence (e.g. diabetes mellitus, elderly patients, connective tissue disorders) could be considered. The fact that rigid rings showed higher dehiscence rates is not surprising, since rigid rings do not alter their shape during the dynamic changes of the mitral annulus across the cardiac cycle, thus increasing biomechanical stress. Moreover, dehiscence was also more frequently observed among patients with ischaemic MR. The authors state that this is possibly explained by excessive annular downsizing and by the progressive nature of LV remodeling/dilation, which together lead to an increase of the pulling forces on the sutures, that attach the annuloplasty ring to the annular tissue. Considering suture reinforcement during annuloplasty (i.e. using more sutures) and utilizing semi-rigid annuloplasty rings may be an advisable technical strategy in this specific subset of patients to avoid undesired dehiscence. Along all the mentioned aspects that can lead to ring dehiscence, the importance of the surgeon’s experience cannot be overemphasized. Moreover, in addition to the technical details to improve MV repair quality and durability in patients with ischaemic MR, adherence to optimal medical therapy is of utmost importance to reduce the risk of disease progression and residual/recurrent MR [3], which subsequently may increase the risk of ring dehiscence. The main limitation of the study by Arjomandi Rad et al. is the lack of information and the missing analysis of technical details related to annuloplasty ring implantation and specific annular tissue characteristics. The influence of tissue composition on the location of the ring dehiscence has been previously reported by our group. We observed that mitral ring dehiscence occurs more frequently in the posterior annulus, especially P3 area, due to a lower collagen density [1]. Therefore, a deeper and more detailed analysis of specific dehiscence risk factors are still needed to identify those weaknesses that can be surgically corrected by modifications of the operative technique. Another important limitation of the current analysis is that only one of the included papers [4] reported tricuspid ring dehiscence. Hence, no strong conclusions can be drawn from this current systematic review regarding tricuspid ring dehiscence. In conclusion, the findings by Arjomandi Rad et al. restore the interest on this topic and gave rise to many still unanswered questions, whose answer could one day finally complete the yet untold story of annuloplasty ring dehiscence after MV or TV repair. Conflicts of interest: none declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marin‐Cuartas et al. (2021) conducted an editorial in Mitral and tricuspid annuloplasty ring dehiscence. Rigid annuloplasty rings vs. Semi-rigid and flexible rings was evaluated on Mitral ring dehiscence (p=<0.001). Mitral ring dehiscence rates were higher among patients with rigid rings compared to semi-rigid and flexible rings.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: