Key result
Balloon angioplasty using high-compliance balloons resulted in an 83.9% primary angiographic success rate compared to 78.9% with low-compliance balloons.
Why the study?
Does balloon angioplasty using highly compliant balloons improve angiographic results and clinical outcomes compared to low-compliant balloons in patients with primary stenoses of native coronary vessels?
RCT (n=800)
randomized
Does balloon angioplasty using highly compliant balloons improve angiographic results and clinical outcomes compared to low-compliant balloons in patients with primary stenoses of native coronary vessels?
There is no objective reason to prefer low- or high-compliance balloons for coronary angioplasty based on clinical or angiographic outcomes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
High-compliance balloons confer no clinically meaningful angiographic advantage; supports no preference over low-compliance balloons in native coronary stenoses.
We randomized 800 patients in a prospective study comparing the angiographic results, device usage and in-hospital outcome of balloon angioplasty of primary stenoses of native coronary vessels with low-compliant and highly compliant balloons. The cumulative incidence of prespecified clinical endpoints was 8.0% in both treatment groups. The primary angiographic success rates were 83.9% and 78.9% in the high- and low-compliance group, respectively (P = 0.05). For the lesions dilated with one study balloon only, the quantitative angiographic findings were virtually identical in the two treatment groups. The total number of dissections was slightly but not significantly higher in the lesions treated with a highly compliant balloon. The global usage of angioplasty balloons was similar in both treatment groups. We conclude that, in general, there is no objective reason to prefer one balloon material to another on the basis of its compliance characteristics.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Desmet et al. (1997) conducted an RCT in Primary stenoses of native coronary vessels (n=800). High-compliance balloons vs. Low-compliance balloons was evaluated on Primary angiographic success rate (p=0.05). Balloon angioplasty using high-compliance balloons resulted in an 83.9% primary angiographic success rate compared to 78.9% with low-compliance balloons.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: