Key result
Previously sedentary women successfully used the Feeling Scale to self-regulate exercise intensity near their ventilatory threshold, with higher physiological intensity achieved during cycling compared to treadmill exercise.
Why the study?
Can previously sedentary females use the Feeling Scale to regulate exercise intensity in a gym environment?
Observational (n=14)
No
Can previously sedentary females use the Feeling Scale to regulate exercise intensity in a gym environment?
Sedentary women can effectively use the Feeling Scale to self-regulate exercise intensity in a natural gym setting, achieving physiological levels sufficient for cardiovascular gains, particularly during cycling.
May support Feeling Scale for self-regulated exercise in sedentary women; extends lab findings but leaves open adherence and outcome benefits in trials.
BACKGROUND: Recent research suggests that the Feeling Scale (FS) can be used as a method of exercise intensity regulation to maintain a positive affective response during exercise. However, research to date has been carried out in laboratories and is not representative of natural exercise environments. The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether sedentary women can self-regulate their exercise intensity using the FS to experience positive affective responses in a gym environment using their own choice of exercise mode; cycling or treadmill. METHODS: Fourteen females (24.9 years ± 5.2; height 166.7 ± 5.7 cm; mass 66.3 ± 13.4 kg; BMI 24.1 ± 5.5)) completed a submaximal exercise test and each individual's ventilatory threshold ([Formula: see text]) was identified. Following this, three 20 min gym-based exercise trials, either on a bike or treadmill were performed at an intensity that was self-selected and perceived to correspond to the FS value of +3 (good). Oxygen uptake, heart rate (HR) and ratings of perceived exertion (RPE) were measured during exercise at the participants chosen intensity. RESULTS: Results indicated that on average participants worked close to their [Formula: see text] and increased their exercise intensity during the 20-min session. Participants worked physiologically harder during cycling exercise. Consistency of oxygen uptake, HR and RPE across the exercise trials was high. CONCLUSION: The data indicate that previously sedentary women can use the FS in an ecological setting to regulate their exercise intensity and that regulating intensity to feel 'good' should lead to individuals exercising at an intensity that would result in cardiovascular gains if maintained.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hamlyn-Williams et al. (2015) conducted an observational in Sedentary lifestyle (n=14). Self-regulated exercise using the Feeling Scale (FS +3) was evaluated on Exercise intensity relative to ventilatory threshold (VO2 as % VO2VT, %HR at VT, and RPE). Previously sedentary women successfully used the Feeling Scale to self-regulate exercise intensity near their ventilatory threshold, with higher physiological intensity achieved during cycling compared to treadmill exercise.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: