Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Conceptual analysis reveals limitations regarding materiality in Alexanderian cultural sociology, suggesting a shift toward nonlinear models of meaning.
In this article, I respond to the overview and exegesis of Alexander's sociology provided by Villegas and Watts. I explore their case for the theorist's ‘canonization’ and outline what they see as the major ‘commitments’ of his social theory. As someone who self-defines as a cultural sociologist, I am particularly interested in what the authors term the ‘multidimensionality’ and ‘postpositivism’ of Alexander's thought. However, I also note Villegas and Watts identify a possible shortcoming: namely, whether Alexander's cultural sociology pays sufficient attention to the materiality of social life. What I call ‘Cultural Sociology 2.0’ has linked meaning to materiality more explicitly; and rather than positing culture as an ‘independent’ or ‘dependent’ variable has gravitated towards nonlinear models of culture. I conclude by asking whether cultural sociology is a style of analysis; and suggest both preserving the ‘black boxes’ of meaning and being attentive to things at the ‘edges’ of comprehension.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Eduardo de la Fuente (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: