Key result
Diagonal and lateral belt loading resulted in an elastic response approximately three times stiffer than hub loading, while maximally contracted thoracic musculature had minimal effect.
Thoracic structural response to loading is primarily influenced by the anatomical structures engaged (especially shoulder involvement) rather than muscle tone, providing guidelines for thoracic models.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Thoracic belt-loading data should not inform clinical practice; leaves open refinement of human thoracic models prioritizing anatomy over muscle.
Thoracic deformation under an applied load is an established indicator of injury risk, but the force required to achieve an injurious level of deformation currently is not understood adequately. This article evaluates how two potentially important factors, loading condition and muscle tensing, affect the structural response of the dynamically loaded thorax. Structural models of two human cadaver thoraxes and two porcine thoraxes were used to quantify the effects. The human cadavers, which represent anthropometric extremes, were subjected to anterior loading from (1) a 5.1-cm-wide belt oriented diagonally (i.e., seatbelt-like loading), (2) a 15.2-cm-diameter rigid hub, and (3) a 20.3-cm-wide belt oriented laterally (i.e., a distributed load). A structural model having the mathematical formulation of a quasilinear viscoelastic material model was used to model the elastic and viscous response, with ramp-hold tests used to determine the model coefficients. The effect of thoracic musculature was assessed using similar ramp-hold tests on the porcine subjects, each with and without forced muscle contraction. Even maximally contracted thoracic musculature is shown to have a minimal effect on the response, with similar elastic and viscous characteristics exhibited by each subject regardless of muscle tone. The elastic response is shown to be approximately a factor of three stiffer for diagonal belt loading and for this distributed loading condition than for the hub loading, indicating that the response is influenced most by the particular anatomical structures that are engaged and, secondarily, by the area of load application. Specifically, shoulder involvement is shown to have a strong influence. The force relaxation is found to be pronounced, but insensitive to the loading condition, with long-time force relaxation coefficients (G( infinity )) in the range of 0.1 to 0.3. The findings of this study provide restraint-specific guidelines for the force-deflection characteristics of both physical and computational thoracic models.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kent et al. (2003) studied Thoracic deformation and injury risk (n=4). Different loading conditions (diagonal belt, lateral belt) and forced muscle contraction vs. Rigid hub loading and no forced muscle contraction was evaluated on Elastic and viscous characteristics of the thorax. Diagonal and lateral belt loading resulted in an elastic response approximately three times stiffer than hub loading, while maximally contracted thoracic musculature had minimal effect.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: