Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The continued advancements in high performance computing, both in hardware and software, and the cost competitive advantage of numerical simulations over laboratory experiments have made computational fluid dynamics an integral tool in the study of science and engineering problems. However, unlike experimental methods for which a large body of knowledge and techniques exist for the evaluation of experimental error and uncertainty (and are widely accepted), equivalent techniques for the evaluation of numerical error and uncertainty are less well developed and accepted. A recent article in the Journal of Fluids Engineering (Celik, 1993) highlighted this point and identified possible reasons for both the lack of interest in this topic and lack of accepted methods for the evaluation of uncertainty by the computational science community. Celik went on to identify three major topics of relevance to the issue of numerical accuracy and uncertainty. These are: (i) the separation of numerical errors from modeling errors; (ii) the identification, estimation, and reduction of numerical errors; and (iii) the assessment of codes and computational schemes with respect to numerical uncertainty through benchmarking. As Celik indicated, there is the need to improve the quality of the large number of papers being published today in computational fluid dynamics, and thus there is an urgent need for implementing a policy regarding numerical uncertainty analysis or quantitative error estimation.The Fluids Engineering Division (FED) of the ASME, through the Coordinating Group on Computational Fluid Dynamics (CGCFD), has taken on the task of leading the computational fluid dynamics community and focusing their attention on the formulation of reasonable measures for numerical accuracy. The CGCFD has by charter the responsibility to promote discussion and interest in research into all areas of computational fluid dynamics and principal among these are methods for the evaluation of numerical accuracy. The CGCFD has performed its function by conducting symposia, forums, and panel discussions addressing this complex topic. The objective here is to delineate standard practices by which computational studies may be performed and the standards by which archival publications will be gauged. As a result of these meetings and discussions a new level of standards for the evaluation of journal publications has been promulgated for the Journal of Fluids Engineering.The Journal of Fluids Engineering has had the policy that it: will not accept for publication any paper reporting the numerical solution of a fluids engineering problem that fails to address the task of systematic truncation error testing and accuracy estimation. This policy statement, originally presented in Roache, Ghia, and White (1986), was the first of its kind and provided a very general standard for evaluating journal publications. In the seven years since this policy's implementation, significant advances in computer hardware and computational software have occurred such that CFD is no longer in its infancy, but is a full-fledged tool in engineering and scientific problem solving. As Roache, Ghia, and White (1986) point out, fifteen years before the publication of their editorial, any successful calculation was of interest, and much of this exploratory work deserved publication. But even in their time it was recognized that this practice was outmoded. Therefore, it seems only logical and scientifically correct that the CFD community meet higher standards for evaluation of accuracy, standards on par with those required of the experimental community. What follows below then, are refinements and enhancements to the Journal's original statement on numerical accuracy, which attempt to elucidate the criteria by which Journal papers will be judged.Finally, it is not the intent of this new policy statement to eliminate a class of simulations which some have referred to as “practical engineering project simulations.” The justification by these individuals for performing a single grid simulation has been that budget constraints, schedule constraints, or computer resource constraints prevent a systematic analysis of accuracy from being performed. It is assumed that in performing CFD analyses for “practical engineering projects,” for which experimental data is usually not available, that one must perform, in the natural course of the project, an evaluation of the accuracy of the simulation results in order to determine the validity of these particular calculations. Without such an effort there is no clear justification for presenting a simulation as representative of the physical phenomena. Therefore, it would seem only natural, even in the solution of practical engineering problems, that the items addressed here, be used to validate a simulation.The author wishes to acknowledge the comments and suggestions to this new policy statement from Prof. B. P. Leonard (University of Akron), Dr. P. J. Roache (Ecodynamics), Dr. Ramesh Agarwal (McDonnell Douglas), Prof. Oktay Baysal (Old Dominion University), and Prof Demetri Telionis (Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University).The guidelines on the following page have been approved by the FED Coordinating Group on Computational Fluid Mechanics and the Editorial Board of the Journal.Although no standard method for evaluating numerical uncertainty is currently accepted by the CFD community, there are numerous methods and techniques available to the user to accomplish this task. The following is a list of guidelines, enumerating the criteria to be considered for archival publication of computational results in the Journal of Fluids EngineeringThese ten items lay down a set of criteria by which the editors and reviewers of this Journal will judge the archival quality of publications dealing with computational studies for the Journal of Fluids Engineering. We recognize that the effort to perform a thorough study of numerical accuracy may be great and that many practical engineering calculations will continue to be performed by first order methods, on a single fixed grid. However, such analyses would not be appropriate for presentation in this archival journal. With the gains in performance of low-end workstations, it is now reasonable to require papers on solutions by CFD to meet these fundamental criteria for archiving of a publication.With the details of these ten criteria now presented, a shortened statement will appear in each volume of the journal. This statement will appear as follows:The Journal of Fluids Engineering will not consider any paper reporting the numerical solution of a fluids engineering problem that fails to address the task of systematic truncation error testing and accuracy estimation. Authors should address the following criteria for assessing numerical uncertainty.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christopher J. Freitas (1993) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: