Key result
A phenotype-informed body composition framework in HF reveals similar BMI values mask distinct risk profiles.
Why the study?
In established HF, BMI shows an apparent discrepancy with waist-based measures and reflects a composite of adipose tissue, fluid accumulation, and skeletal muscle wasting, complicating body composition interpretation.
This review proposes a phenotype-informed framework for assessing body composition in heart failure, emphasizing that BMI alone masks distinct clinical phenotypes defined by adiposity, congestion, and muscle mass.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant caution using BMI alone for risk stratification in heart failure; leaves open prospective validation of phenotype-informed body composition assessment.
Body mass index (BMI) and waist-based anthropometric indices are widely used to estimate adiposity and cardiometabolic risk. Yet in established heart failure (HF), modestly higher BMI is associated with improved survival, while waist-based measures show a linear association with worse outcomes. This apparent discrepancy suggests that the biological interpretation of BMI and body composition changes once HF develops. In HF, BMI reflects the composite of adipose tissue, fluid accumulation, and skeletal muscle wasting, whereas waist-based indices primarily reflect central adiposity. In this narrative review, we explore the challenges of body composition interpretation in HF and propose a conceptual, phenotype-informed framework for body composition assessment and management. Within this framework, BMI may mask biologically distinct yet clinically relevant phenotypes defined by adiposity, congestion, and skeletal muscle integrity. By integrating these interacting components, the framework highlights that similar BMI values may represent biologically distinct phenotypes with different risk profiles and potential management implications. Across BMI categories, preserved muscle mass and limited congestion are associated with more favorable outcomes, whereas central adiposity, congestion, and muscle wasting identify higher-risk states. This conceptual framework provides a foundation for future research and may ultimately inform more individualized body composition assessment, risk stratification, and management of patients with HF.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hoef et al. (2026) conducted a review in Heart Failure. Body composition assessment was evaluated. A phenotype-informed framework for body composition in heart failure suggests that similar BMI values may represent biologically distinct phenotypes with different risk profiles.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: