Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor, We read with great interest the critical analysis of our work (Cuellar, 2017). We appreciate the opportunity to respond, and to provide clarification regarding the purpose of our validated Predicting Abusive Head Trauma (PredAHT) clinical prediction tool (Maguire et al., 2011; Cowley et al., 2015). In the abstract and throughout the article, Cuellar has somewhat oversimplified the objective of PredAHT, stating that it was developed ‘to make an AHT diagnosis’ (Cuellar, 2017, p. 223). We emphasize that PredAHT was not designed to be a diagnostic tool, but as an aid to ‘assist frontline professionals when deciding whether to refer a child for specialist clinical and multiagency investigation of possible AHT’ (Maguire et al., 2011, p. e558). As with other clinical prediction tools, PredAHT must be used in combination with all clinical, forensic, historical and psychosocial information available in each individual case. It ‘will not confirm or exclude AHT in isolation’ (Cowley et al., 2015, p. 296), and ‘will never replace the diagnostic skills of the clinician’ (Maguire et al., 2011, p. e558). We are somewhat puzzled by the statement in the abstract, that PredAHT is ‘an inappropriate foundation upon which to base an opinion that will be used in a criminal prosecution’. We would agree entirely, as we have never suggested that the purpose of this clinical tool is for use as the foundation or basis of an opinion for a criminal prosecution, but rather that it may ‘assist clinicians offering medical testimony in civil or criminal proceedings, in demonstrating why certain combinations of features are more or less predictive of an abusive etiology’ (Maguire et al., 2011, p.e558). This is a tool for clinicians to gauge the likelihood of AHT in a child with a given set of clinical features and not a tool designed for legal purposes per se; we fully acknowledge that medicine cannot do the job of the law. The role of the clinician in the UK, together with the children’s social care team is to determine, on the balance of probability, whether the child has suffered from child abuse such that the family can be supported and the child and siblings can be protected from future harm. Clinical prediction tools, including PredAHT, are designed for use by clinicians when they are assessing patients with complex conditions. PredAHT can be used as a basis to explain to the courts how, at a certain point in the clinical assessment process, the different clinical findings come together to identify cases that should be fully evaluated to confirm or exclude AHT. However, PredAHT should not be used as the sole piece of evidence, nor should it be considered to be a diagnostic tool that can categorically or definitively determine whether or not AHT occurred. In a legal setting, this is the job of the jury and judge, who, like the clinician, must consider all available evidence in their decisions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cowley et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: